I Don’t Understand this Forum?

DainW

Hey guys relatively new to the forum, maybe within the last 6 months or so. Not sure I understand what’s going on here? 

Post a money brisket cook, get like 5 responses. Post something about Tiger Woods or something political, 100+ responses in a couple of hours, forum moderators have to shut it down. 

Also can someone explain any unwritten rules about posting cooks? I read somewhere it’s considered poor form to have silverware in the shot? Is that right? Anything else like that? 

Canugghead

Belated welcome!

To put it bluntly, without the shenanigans this place will be as boring as hell 

Want proof? take a look at greeneggers.com

edit: this thread can generate 100+ responses 

McStew

-pictures or it didn't happen 
-no silverware 
-welcome to the Sh** show

Photo Egg

No reason to try and apply logic to a forum. Yes, most other forums are much better moderated. And you better get used to seeing Off Topic posts getting more hits than your food posts.
Just roll with it and read the ones you want.
And screw the fork in the picture rule.
The only real rule...If you don’t post a photo...your cook never happened!

WeberWho

A good portion of people who post here have been on the forum for years. So a good portion of us have seen many, many briskets, ribs, pulled pork posts etc. I have zero issue and more than likely click on the post to check it out as I'm always learning something. 

The silverware is more of a inside joke with a forum member and not liking forks in pictures. 

lousubcap

You have been here long enough to know that there are hot button topics that will generate lots of comments and debate.  It makes this a more friendly place unless it is late at night and the adult beverages are flowing, then it can get less friendly.  
There are many non BBQ related subjects that get posted here as the forum breadth of talents and skills run across the spectrum.  Lots of useful information to be had in those topics and generally lots of interest. 
In general, "normal" cook posts will generate a few comments but since there is nothing out of the ordinary, there is nothing to generate excitement.  When a unique and first-time posted cook shows up it will garner many comments as it is new to most here.
I am unaware of any unwritten rules.  Some members may object to the silverware (most specifically forks) but that's a personal issue. 
All above just my opinion and observations.  FWIW-
BTW- this place can put a hurt on your discretionary $$ 

SmokeyPitt

It sounds like you understand this forum perfectly.

fishlessman

im good with the silverware, just dont put a bassboat in your yard

SciAggie

Hang in there. I was confused as a noob too. 
As far as silverware (especially forks) - it's an etiquette thing. Many people are repulsed by the thought of a tool that's been sloshed arounf inside someone's mouth and then displayed on a plate.

Posting cooks:
You'll post cooks that get 50 views and 2 comments. You'll post cooks that get hundreds of views and many comments. It's how it goes. Just post cooks you want to post my friend. People will get to know you and make comments. 

OT threads - yes they blow up and get lots of views and comments. Train yourself early. If you don't like those threads just don't read them. Read the threads that interest you and let the rest go.

A few trolls are around. As my momma would say, "They would argue with a post." (fence post)
Opinions are like anal sphincters - we all have them - and will share them. Over time you'll learn the folks here you want to listen to for advice. Argue if you want, or don't. This is just a BBQ forum on the internet - we ain't changing the world's views on anything.

Above all, have some fun here. Join the Friday night zoom - put some names and faces together. Cook, post, eat, drink, sleep, repeat.

Botch

McStew said:

-pictures or it didn't happen 
-no silverware 
-welcome to the Sh** show

I thought the rule was "no dirty silverware".  
 
















  

caliking

Welcome to the jungle!

The first rule is... that there are no rules

Well there sort of are. Mainly, just be a decent person. That is harder for some, than for most. 

This forum is loosely moderated, which I  personally think is its strength. Its moderated to some degree by the natives. It generally works out. 

Post your cooks, your fails, your pets, etc. Some will be liked, some won't. It's all good. 

Lastly, remember not to take it too personally. It's just the internet.

WeberWho

fishlessman said:

im good with the silverware, just dont put a bassboat in your yard

I knew my neighbors would be cool with this in the yard.

SonVolt

Home-Barista.com is the premier coffee forum on the web and it's moderated just like you describe - every topic has to be about coffee and anything off topic is deleted with a stern warning sent to your mailbox from the mods.  While that works great for keeping the forum 100% educational, it really becomes quite a bore for long-time members who, year after year, keep seeing different permutations of the same topics over and over.  "Does anyone else grind their own beans?"  In short, it because more like a Wiki than a community. 

Hope that helps. 

Roasted Squash Ravioli with w/browned butter & sage. I stuck the fork in my butt.

Canugghead

Canugghead said:

Belated welcome!

To put it bluntly, without the shenanigans this place will be as boring as hell 

Want proof? take a look at greeneggers.com

edit: this thread can generate 100+ responses 

See what I mean?  Your amazing brisket thread generated and stopped at 9 responses in three days.  This one got 12 responses in about 30 minutes 

edit: just noticed you posted this thread in the 'beef' category?!

JohnInCarolina

Like any other forum, it's not for everyone.  I do think most people are able to find what they need here, if they're willing to look hard enough for it.

People who post threads with questions usually get answers pretty quickly, and more than one.  I think that's probably a lot more helpful and important than just about anything else that goes on here.

On occasion, the quality content is kind of hidden.  For example, right now one of my favorite threads here is the "What are you Chef-ing tonight, Dr?" thread.  There are some great cooks that get posted there.  I am routinely blown away. 

Off topic threads like the one about Woods can get a lot of attention if and when shenanigans come into effect.  Otherwise, many times they just die on the vine. 

The last thing that's probably important to mention is that you can legit make some new friends through this forum, if you want to.  In non-pandemic times people are routinely meeting up at Eggfests and whatnot, and personally I think it is a lot easier for many new people to go to one of those for the first time if they know at least someone on the forum they've interacted with will be there.  

SGH

DainW said:

Not sure I understand what’s going on here? 

You are not alone my friend. No one understands what is going on here. It is a strange and mysterious place. No rhyme or reason to anything.

dbCooper

@DainW

BGE officially states this:

"The Only Rules That Matter: 
Enjoy your visit, keep cooking on your Big Green Egg, and above all, have fun sharing recipes and experiences on the EGGhead Forum. Thanks for visiting."

From here:

https://eggheadforum.com/discussion/1134015/rules-disclaimer

I see no mention of forks in their rules.  

fishlessman

dbCooper said:

@DainW

BGE officially states this:

"The Only Rules That Matter: 
Enjoy your visit, keep cooking on your Big Green Egg, and above all, have fun sharing recipes and experiences on the EGGhead Forum. Thanks for visiting."

From here:

https://eggheadforum.com/discussion/1134015/rules-disclaimer

I see no mention of forks in their rules.  

so all the other rules the buffalo sneaks in are just enforceable unofficial rules

vb4677

If you want a good answer, then ask a good question - give all the details of your BGE/Cooking question - cover all the variables - time, temp, lump type & volume, vent opening sizes, time of day, windspeed, how much bourbon/beer was in you at that time, all that.  For the most part, people are willing to help you get the most of your BGE, but they gotta know some of this to help!

Share a little of your successes - again, right up the details so other newbies can see how to cook on these things. 

And you could've cooked the most majestic ribeye for the Pope, but no one will believe you without a photo...

Ozzie_Isaac

SciAggie said:

Hang in there. I was confused as a noob too. 
As far as silverware (especially forks) - it's an etiquette thing. Many people are repulsed by the thought of a tool that's been sloshed arounf inside someone's mouth and then displayed on a plate.

Posting cooks:
You'll post cooks that get 50 views and 2 comments. You'll post cooks that get hundreds of views and many comments. It's how it goes. Just post cooks you want to post my friend. People will get to know you and make comments. 

OT threads - yes they blow up and get lots of views and comments. Train yourself early. If you don't like those threads just don't read them. Read the threads that interest you and let the rest go.

A few trolls are around. As my momma would say, "They would argue with a post." (fence post)
Opinions are like anal sphincters - we all have them - and will share them. Over time you'll learn the folks here you want to listen to for advice. Argue if you want, or don't. This is just a BBQ forum on the internet - we ain't changing the world's views on anything.

Above all, have some fun here. Join the Friday night zoom - put some names and faces together. Cook, post, eat, drink, sleep, repeat.

What other kind of post would you argue with?  Fence posts are ****.

SonVolt

SciAggie

Ozzie_Isaac said:

SciAggie said:

Hang in there. I was confused as a noob too. 
As far as silverware (especially forks) - it's an etiquette thing. Many people are repulsed by the thought of a tool that's been sloshed arounf inside someone's mouth and then displayed on a plate.

Posting cooks:
You'll post cooks that get 50 views and 2 comments. You'll post cooks that get hundreds of views and many comments. It's how it goes. Just post cooks you want to post my friend. People will get to know you and make comments. 

OT threads - yes they blow up and get lots of views and comments. Train yourself early. If you don't like those threads just don't read them. Read the threads that interest you and let the rest go.

A few trolls are around. As my momma would say, "They would argue with a post." (fence post)
Opinions are like anal sphincters - we all have them - and will share them. Over time you'll learn the folks here you want to listen to for advice. Argue if you want, or don't. This is just a BBQ forum on the internet - we ain't changing the world's views on anything.

Above all, have some fun here. Join the Friday night zoom - put some names and faces together. Cook, post, eat, drink, sleep, repeat.

What other kind of post would you argue with?  Fence posts are ****.

Not to be confused with forum post, lol. My mom used to say that all the time...

Ozzie_Isaac

SciAggie said:

Ozzie_Isaac said:

SciAggie said:

Hang in there. I was confused as a noob too. 
As far as silverware (especially forks) - it's an etiquette thing. Many people are repulsed by the thought of a tool that's been sloshed arounf inside someone's mouth and then displayed on a plate.

Posting cooks:
You'll post cooks that get 50 views and 2 comments. You'll post cooks that get hundreds of views and many comments. It's how it goes. Just post cooks you want to post my friend. People will get to know you and make comments. 

OT threads - yes they blow up and get lots of views and comments. Train yourself early. If you don't like those threads just don't read them. Read the threads that interest you and let the rest go.

A few trolls are around. As my momma would say, "They would argue with a post." (fence post)
Opinions are like anal sphincters - we all have them - and will share them. Over time you'll learn the folks here you want to listen to for advice. Argue if you want, or don't. This is just a BBQ forum on the internet - we ain't changing the world's views on anything.

Above all, have some fun here. Join the Friday night zoom - put some names and faces together. Cook, post, eat, drink, sleep, repeat.

What other kind of post would you argue with?  Fence posts are ****.

Not to be confused with forum post, lol. My mom used to say that all the time...

My wife tells me I would argue with a brick wall.

Ozzie_Isaac

vb4677 said:

If you want a good answer, then ask a good question - give all the details of your BGE/Cooking question - cover all the variables - time, temp, lump type & volume, vent opening sizes, time of day, windspeed, how much bourbon/beer was in you at that time, all that.  For the most part, people are willing to help you get the most of your BGE, but they gotta know some of this to help!

Share a little of your successes - again, right up the details so other newbies can see how to cook on these things. 

And you could've cooked the most majestic ribeye for the Pope, but no one will believe you without a photo...

Pope likes New York Strip, fyi.

alaskanassasin

the tiger thread got nuked?

JohnInCarolina

alaskanassasin said:

the tiger thread got nuked?

Yep.  Can't imagine why, lol

Ozzie_Isaac

JohnInCarolina said:

alaskanassasin said:

the tiger thread got nuked?

Yep.  Can't imagine why, lol

Turns out the Buffalo is a huge Karin Baskin fan.

CPARKTX2

There is a ton of knowledge on the forum, and if you post questions, you will usually get really good responses.  The quantity of cooking posts has gone down over time, but a lot of friendships have been formed here.  Lots of people have met up in person at Eggfests and the like.  Welcome to the group...give it a try.

FarmingPhD

First rule about the forum, we don’t talk about the rules, second rule about the forum, we don’t talk about the rules.....

ahhhhh Friday my old friend.

HeavyG

dbCooper said:

@DainW

BGE officially states this:

"The Only Rules That Matter: 
Enjoy your visit, keep cooking on your Big Green Egg, and above all, have fun sharing recipes and experiences on the EGGhead Forum. Thanks for visiting."

From here:

https://eggheadforum.com/discussion/1134015/rules-disclaimer

I see no mention of forks in their rules.  

I see no mention of actually posting pix of food.

Ozzie_Isaac

Btw, this is one of the only places where you can have a cook going sideways at 2am in the morning and you will get help.