Returning an Item to Costco....

TEXASBGE2018

I know you folks on here swear by Costco and their return policy. I have a question. What's the longest you've had something that you returned to Costco? My reason for asking this is that my wife and I bought a Prelit Christmas Tree about 7 years ago from Costco that stopped working about 2 years ago. Rather than trying to return it I've kept it and just added new lights the last couple years. If I don't have a receipt would they have a history of it anywhere and also would they take this back? It was around $300 when we bought it and if I can take advantage of Costco's supposed lifetime guarantee I will before shelling out another $300 for another tree. Any thoughts?

lousubcap

I would call/visit the source; Costco.

TEXASBGE2018

lousubcap said:

I would call/visit the source; Costco.

Ya, I've been trying to call today but apparently their entire phone system is down because every number I've called says its not in service. I plan on giving them a shout but just figured I would ask on here to get a gauge.

NorthPilot06

Standing by...if you're able to return/exchange, that would be impressive.

buzd504

TEXASBGE2018 said:

lousubcap said:

I would call/visit the source; Costco.

Ya, I've been trying to call today but apparently their entire phone system is down because every number I've called says its not in service. I plan on giving them a shout but just figured I would ask on here to get a gauge.

They will probably take it back regardless of your documentation.  That's how they roll.

TEXASBGE2018

Ya, I really don't wanna be THAT GUY who returns an 8 year old fake Christmas tree but these dang "real looking" ones are expensive. If I can get a replacement or at least my money back its worth driving the 4 miles up there to try.

WeberWho

I'd say it's a pretty good run for 8 years and call it good. Just me personally though. 

JohnnyTarheel

I doubt you would be asking if you didn’t think it’s really not the right thing to do. You did get 5 years use out of it.....

TEXASBGE2018

JohnnyTarheel said:

I doubt you would be asking if you didn’t think it’s really not the right thing to do. You did get 5 years use out of it.....

Ya, 5 years of use is ok. I've just never tried to return anything to Costco before. However, seeing as I saw 2 guys back to back returning clearly well used Kamado Joe's to Costco and getting their money back I thought to myself, returning a Christmas tree that had the bulbs burn out is a little less douchy than that. So am I really that awful for at least looking into it?

JohnnyTarheel

I hear you.. I just sort of look at it as if I got reasonable use out of it I got what I paid for it. They do have a lenient return policy... and like anything some returns are legit and some not...

SmokeyPitt

Have you checked to make sure it is not just a fuse? I have one that is pre-lit but just uses standard cheap string lights. 

https://www.lightsforalloccasions.com/p-4347-how-to-change-your-globe-string-lights-fuse.aspx

TEXASBGE2018

SmokeyPitt said:

Have you checked to make sure it is not just a fuse? I have one that is pre-lit but just uses standard cheap string lights. 

https://www.lightsforalloccasions.com/p-4347-how-to-change-your-globe-string-lights-fuse.aspx

Ya, I tried but because this thing is pre-lit they seem to have special lights. I couldn't find a fuse box on it. They aren't LED's so I know there has to be one somewhere but I couldn't find it anywhere. I'm probably just gonna bite the bullet and get another one. Just wanted to see if maybe someone had an experience doing something similar so I wouldn't feel so bad....

blasting

If the buck fiddy hot dog goes up in price I'm holding you responsible.

Woodchunk

https://www.businessinsider.com/costco-membership-canceled-return-policy-2018-8

TEXASBGE2018

Ya, I wouldn't go so far as to assume I'm trying to abuse their system. I've never returned anything there before. I am going to try and get a hold of them and just ask them on the phone and be 100% truthful with them. If they tell me "no way scum bag we aren't taking that back". Then fine, I will be more than happy to walk in and buy another $300 tree from them. But if they say "sure, more than happy to help" then why not? I view what I am asking to do a bit differently than returning a used Samsung Washer or Used Dyson Vacuum or sheets. It's a Christmas Tree that I have up for 2 months a year. It's not really "Well used" or anything. Just happens that the middle section of lights went out and again if they seem as if its even somewhat sketchy then fine.

Cornholio

How about accepting the fact that you got several (5?) years out of a plastic tree and recycle it and buy another.  If it sat in a box for two years and then you opened it and realized it was a defective product that would be one thing but you used it for multiple years before it had issues.  People abusing return policies is why places like Nordstrom and REI have had to change theirs.  

Dont be her, returning a (real) Christmas tree in January:

HoustonEgger

Sams club but I would assume similar results - a few years back, I bought a bunch of shorts that were on sale and never ended up wearing them (left tags on). Found them after moving and returned them without a receipt - they were able to go through my account to find the purchase and gave me the refund based on that. 

HeavyG

Woodchunk said:

https://www.businessinsider.com/costco-membership-canceled-return-policy-2018-8

Good for Costco. I remember not too many years ago when they changed their return policy on tv's due to too many douchebags returning a large screen telly after the Super Bowl.

Amazon should probably tighten up their return policy also.

Personally, I wouldn't even think of returning a seven year old item and I've yet to return any items to Costco in twenty some years of membership but if I did I'm sure they would accept it.

TEXASBGE2018

Cornholio said:

How about accepting the fact that you got several (5?) years out of a plastic tree and recycle it and buy another.  If it sat in a box for two years and then you opened it and realized it was a defective product that would be one thing but you used it for multiple years before it had issues.  People abusing return policies is why places like Nordstrom and REI have had to change theirs.  

Dont be her, returning a (real) Christmas tree in January:

Now obviously THAT I would never do. I didn't feel as though asking about my situation was in any way abusing a return policy but apparently several of you think it is. So I have a better gauge now as to what I should do. I'm still going to call and ask them but will most likely end up doing the very thing you stated which is recycle this one and buy a new one. Just asking for feedback and I've gotten it, Thanks everyone!

TEXASBGE2018

HeavyG said:

Woodchunk said:

https://www.businessinsider.com/costco-membership-canceled-return-policy-2018-8

Good for Costco. I remember not too many years ago when they changed their return policy on tv's due to too many douchebags returning a large screen telly after the Super Bowl.

Amazon should probably tighten up their return policy also.

Personally, I wouldn't even think of returning a seven year old item and I've yet to return any items to Costco in twenty some years of membership but if I did I'm sure they would accept it.

So when that lifetime warranty egg has ceramics that crack you just go out and buy a new one every time right?

DoubleEgger

Get a tree from Balsam Hill if you have to buy a new one. It’s money well spent. 

TEXASBGE2018

DoubleEgger said:

Get a tree from Balsam Hill if you have to buy a new one. It’s money well spent. 

Ya I just looked those up. They look pretty nice.

DoubleEgger

TEXASBGE2018 said:

Cornholio said:

How about accepting the fact that you got several (5?) years out of a plastic tree and recycle it and buy another.  If it sat in a box for two years and then you opened it and realized it was a defective product that would be one thing but you used it for multiple years before it had issues.  People abusing return policies is why places like Nordstrom and REI have had to change theirs.  

Dont be her, returning a (real) Christmas tree in January:

Now obviously THAT I would never do. I didn't feel as though asking about my situation was in any way abusing a return policy but apparently several of you think it is. So I have a better gauge now as to what I should do. I'm still going to call and ask them but will most likely end up doing the very thing you stated which is recycle this one and buy a new one. Just asking for feedback and I've gotten it, Thanks everyone!

I’d definitely call them. Why would Costco offer a lifetime warranty if they didn’t intend to stand by it?

 When your egg is 20 years old, are you just going to say it had a good run and go buy another one to avoid looking like a scum bag? 

HeavyG

TEXASBGE2018 said:

HeavyG said:

Woodchunk said:

https://www.businessinsider.com/costco-membership-canceled-return-policy-2018-8

Good for Costco. I remember not too many years ago when they changed their return policy on tv's due to too many douchebags returning a large screen telly after the Super Bowl.

Amazon should probably tighten up their return policy also.

Personally, I wouldn't even think of returning a seven year old item and I've yet to return any items to Costco in twenty some years of membership but if I did I'm sure they would accept it.

So when that lifetime warranty egg has ceramics that crack you just go out and buy a new one every time right?

Yep. Since my dealer delivers fully assembled Eggs I just find that easier to deal with.

It's apples and oranges tho and I suspect you already know that.

What I find most surprising in this whole tale is that there really are folks that buy plastic xmas trees.

TEXASBGE2018

DoubleEgger said:

TEXASBGE2018 said:

Cornholio said:

How about accepting the fact that you got several (5?) years out of a plastic tree and recycle it and buy another.  If it sat in a box for two years and then you opened it and realized it was a defective product that would be one thing but you used it for multiple years before it had issues.  People abusing return policies is why places like Nordstrom and REI have had to change theirs.  

Dont be her, returning a (real) Christmas tree in January:

Now obviously THAT I would never do. I didn't feel as though asking about my situation was in any way abusing a return policy but apparently several of you think it is. So I have a better gauge now as to what I should do. I'm still going to call and ask them but will most likely end up doing the very thing you stated which is recycle this one and buy a new one. Just asking for feedback and I've gotten it, Thanks everyone!

I’d definitely call them. Why would Costco offer a lifetime warranty if they didn’t intend to stand by it?

 When your egg is 20 years old, are you just going to say it had a good run and go buy another one to avoid looking like a scum bag? 

Hence my reply to HeavyG above. I do view it slightly different as the Egg specifically states it comes with a lifetime warranty whereas my situation just relies on Costco standing by their claim to honor a satisfaction guarantee. I get why some people view it as "abusing" the system but I don't for my situation, considering I don't do this on any kind of regular basis and this would be the 1st time in over 10 years of membership with them that I have returned anything. I will see what they say but I'm not gonna get all pissed off if they don't. I will just go spend more money with them because I like them that much.

dmchicago

TEXASBGE2018 said:

JohnnyTarheel said:

I doubt you would be asking if you didn’t think it’s really not the right thing to do. You did get 5 years use out of it.....

Ya, 5 years of use is ok. I've just never tried to return anything to Costco before. However, seeing as I saw 2 guys back to back returning clearly well used Kamado Joe's to Costco and getting their money back I thought to myself, returning a Christmas tree that had the bulbs burn out is a little less douchy than that. So am I really that awful for at least looking into it?

Not exactly setting a high bar for your life, eh? 

TEXASBGE2018

dmchicago said:

TEXASBGE2018 said:

JohnnyTarheel said:

I doubt you would be asking if you didn’t think it’s really not the right thing to do. You did get 5 years use out of it.....

Ya, 5 years of use is ok. I've just never tried to return anything to Costco before. However, seeing as I saw 2 guys back to back returning clearly well used Kamado Joe's to Costco and getting their money back I thought to myself, returning a Christmas tree that had the bulbs burn out is a little less douchy than that. So am I really that awful for at least looking into it?

Not exactly setting a high bar for your life, eh? 

If I keep it that low there’s always room for improvement right?

GATraveller

I'd call and run it by them to see what they say. Can't wait to hear the outcome as I'd be really impressed if they took it back after this long. 

Legume

When BGE honors their warranty, it’s out of their pocket.  When Costco let’s you return anything, I believe it comes out of the vendor’s pocket, regardless of their warranty.  Cost of doing business with Costco.  So it’s different.

I’ve returned a keurig and a vacuum sealer at about the 2.5-3 year mark - basically just exchanged.  More than that and I wouldn’t unless it was something where the product itself has a longer expected lifetime.  I know people that do, but that doesn’t feel right for me.

Eggcelsior

Yes, Costco will take it back. I’ve seen a lot worse returned, no questions asked (former Costco employee here).

mlc2013

first of shame on you for not buying a real tree!!!! Help keep us nursery garden center guys in business. Secondly I sell cost contact@bpiny.com and I get returns from them 3-5 years after selling the item to them so I believe they do not eat the cost of return and just push it to the vendor, hence why I stopped selling them a year ago but will still get a charge back here and there. Im sure they will take it back but is it the right thing to do only you can answer that