Under seasoned Brisket, again!

SmyrnaGA · April 2016

I rarely do briskets, but, when I do, I never get the seasoning right. It's usually under salted & over peppered. But, when I was making this last one. I thought I over seasoned the salt, but, it actually turned out barely salted!?!?! I trim the fat as per Franklin's videos (1/8 inch fat), remove as much silver skin as I can. It's the 'free hand' sprinkling of salt & pepper that's making things off.

Question to forum: How do you "know" you've got enough seasoning?

My plan for the next Brisket is to measure out on a scale EXACTLY how much salt I'll be using based on trimmed weight. Then sprinkle it all on both sides and let her rip.

For those wondering, I use the platesetter legs up. One leg under the hinge in the back. A pizza stone under the 'slot' between the legs under the handle. Fat side down. Point toward the hinge (expose to the most heat). Flat protected by lots of stone in the front. Cook 250 grate level. Start probing at 192 IT until 'butter'.

Image: https://us.v-cdn.net/5017260/uploads/editor/qg/0udiy0x1tlo5.jpg

Image: https://us.v-cdn.net/5017260/uploads/editor/rt/n3ulnv3h1des.jpg

Image: https://us.v-cdn.net/5017260/uploads/editor/av/nx0httfhigmz.jpg

Thatgrimguy · April 2016

Looks like my base layer when I do brisket. I add 2 more kinds of rub on top of that layer though. The Gold Grade I did at Butt Blast last weekend had 3 layers of rub.

First was SPOG, the Oakridge black ops, then Montreal Steak Seasoning. Brisket can really take some rub.

GalanteNate_OneEa · April 2016

Yeah, I'd say your free hand style could be the issue. Measure out equal parts salt and pepper and use a shaker, I bought stainless steal ones but also re-use commercial rub containers. Just make sure the holes are big enough to pass both the salt and pepper and always mix well before using since different seasonings will settle and others find their way to the top. A way to combat that is use seasonings with like coarseness.
just a good even coating and some rest between seasoning and smoking should work.

Good luck!

GoooDawgs · April 2016

When in doubt, I always use more seasoning! I'm intrigued by your set-up though - you said, " A pizza stone under the 'slot' between the legs under the handle." I assume this is to make a larger indirect area. Is this a common practice?? I've never seen this before.

GoooDawgs · April 2016

GoooDawgs said:

When in doubt, I always use more seasoning! I'm intrigued by your set-up though - you said, " A pizza stone under the 'slot' between the legs under the handle." I assume this is to make a larger indirect area. Is this a common practice?? I've never seen this before.

Sorry to quote myself, but would it make more sense to have the platesetter pointed toward the front handle, and then use the pizza stone to take up most of the space towards the back off the egg since that's typically the hot spot?? Sorry to take the topic off track...

The Cen-Tex Smoker · April 2016

SmyrnaGA said:

I rarely do briskets, but, when I do, I never get the seasoning right. It's usually under salted & over peppered. But, when I was making this last one. I thought I over seasoned the salt, but, it actually turned out barely salted!?!?! I trim the fat as per Franklin's videos (1/8 inch fat), remove as much silver skin as I can. It's the 'free hand' sprinkling of salt & pepper that's making things off.

Question to forum: How do you "know" you've got enough seasoning?

My plan for the next Brisket is to measure out on a scale EXACTLY how much salt I'll be using based on trimmed weight. Then sprinkle it all on both sides and let her rip.

For those wondering, I use the platesetter legs up. One leg under the hinge in the back. A pizza stone under the 'slot' between the legs under the handle. Fat side down. Point toward the hinge (expose to the most heat). Flat protected by lots of stone in the front. Cook 250 grate level. Start probing at 192 IT until 'butter'.

I use 3x that much. you can barely see the meat when I'm done. try using a shaker too. that's pretty uneven. I just save old bottles of rub and make my own to put in there.

bgebrent · April 2016

Your thread title defines the problem. Good seasoning advice above!

GalanteNate_OneEa · April 2016

GoooDawgs said:

GoooDawgs said:

When in doubt, I always use more seasoning! I'm intrigued by your set-up though - you said, " A pizza stone under the 'slot' between the legs under the handle." I assume this is to make a larger indirect area. Is this a common practice?? I've never seen this before.

Sorry to quote myself, but would it make more sense to have the platesetter pointed toward the front handle, and then use the pizza stone to take up most of the space towards the back off the egg since that's typically the hot spot?? Sorry to take the topic off track...

I was was curious to know that too. From what I have learned about my egg is that the heat rises from the back of the egg, and I have heard people say they put the leg center in the back to break it up. So I did that for a while until I noticed that the heat didn't really distribute evenly, it just moved from one side to another and I had no control over where it would come from. And knowing where your heat is coming from seemed to be better so that you can control your cook better. Like when you put the point of the brisket to the rear because thickest part towards the heat source seems logical to get a more even cook. The pizza stone trick I definately have never heard but assume it's to keep the heat towards the rear as well?

The Cen-Tex Smoker · April 2016

more like this:

Image: https://us.v-cdn.net/5017260/uploads/editor/i3/73h4pxazyxkg.jpg

admiral21 · April 2016

Here is a Brisket I just did, same setup with the platesetter and pizza stone.

My seasoning was 6 parts Pepper, 2 parts Salt, 4 parts Lawry's. The Seasoning came out perfect. It looks like mine has quite a bit more pepper than yours so I'm guessing it in turn had more salt.

Image: https://us.v-cdn.net/5017260/uploads/editor/qj/uw8hfr3zcsok.jpg

Image: https://us.v-cdn.net/5017260/uploads/editor/vq/de6qn34skbii.jpg

If it does taste under seasoned don't be afraid to really give it some salt. The brisket is a huge hunk of meat and isn't scared of too much seasoning.

SmyrnaGA · April 2016

Thanks for all the advice. I'm definitely gun shy with the salt (high blood pressure and all). I'll bookmark this thread and follow the advice you guys fave shared on my next Brisket (whenever that is).

DoubleEgger · April 2016

Do yourself a favor and run over to Sams BBQ1 on Lower Roswell Rd. and pick up some of their Cow Dust. It's the real deal.

SmyrnaGA · April 2016

GalanteNate_OneEa said:

I was was curious to know that too. From what I have learned about my egg is that the heat rises from the back of the egg, and I have heard people say they put the leg center in the back to break it up. So I did that for a while until I noticed that the heat didn't really distribute evenly, it just moved from one side to another and I had no control over where it would come from. And knowing where your heat is coming from seemed to be better so that you can control your cook better. Like when you put the point of the brisket to the rear because thickest part towards the heat source seems logical to get a more even cook. The pizza stone trick I definately have never heard but assume it's to keep the heat towards the rear as well?

I use this setup to "mimic" an offset. Watching the Franklin videos, he says the airflow and heat hits the point first and then the flat. I know the smoke won't flow like that in the egg, but, the heat would. I like the results this way since more fat seems to render out the point and I get really crispy crust back there. I guess I could trim more and use a more traditional setup. But, I'll be happy if I can just be consistent.

lousubcap · April 2016

@SmyrnaGA - I too go lighter with the salt to pepper ratio but always ensure I make up for it with garlic and paprika. Lay down a solid covering of your preferred rub (give it a taste test before you do) and you should be fine. No bare meat spots. FWIW-

bgebrent · April 2016

DoubleEgger said:

Do yourself a favor and run over to Sams BBQ1 on Lower Roswell Rd. and pick up some of their Cow Dust. It's the real deal.

Gave some of the Sam's BBQ1 brisket rub to @Eggcelsior, @DMW and @Thatgrimguy. You turned me onto that great rub. This is good advice and use it liberally!

HendersonTRKing · April 2016

Franklin's videos call for 1/2 coarse salt, 1/2 coarse pepper. He even shows you how to distribute it -- what height to let it fall from, how to make sure it gets on he sides, etc. Because I'm not Him, I tend to load it up pretty good. Haven't had an under seasoning problem yet.

Thatgrimguy · April 2016

Butt blast brisket

SGH · May 2016

@SmyrnaGA
Always remember, the amount of seasoning that you use up front is a direct reflection of what you will end up with in the end. Here are 3 different examples from light to heavy.
First, some ribs dusted ever so lightly with just salt and cayenne. Notice the pretty mahogany color in the absence of heavy bark.

Next, a brisket with a medium dusting of various seasonings.

Sorry that I don't have a better pic. But you can see the medium bark to a degree in this pic.

Image: https://us.v-cdn.net/5017260/uploads/editor/2u/ymy34lgra8ip.jpeg

Last but not least, a very heavy seasoning. You can clearly see the difference that it makes with bark formation.

If you want a heavy bark, don't be scared to put it to it. The more the better up to a point.

johnnyp · May 2016

Don't be shy

johnmitchell · May 2016

Thatgrimguy said:

Looks like my base layer when I do brisket. I add 2 more kinds of rub on top of that layer though. The Gold Grade I did at Butt Blast last weekend had 3 layers of rub.

First was SPOG, the Oakridge black ops, then Montreal Steak Seasoning. Brisket can really take some rub.

Let me tell you that was the best thing I have ever tasted... Spot on..

shadowrider · May 2016

SmyrnaGA said:

Thanks for all the advice. I'm definitely gun shy with the salt (high blood pressure and all). I'll bookmark this thread and follow the advice you guys fave shared on my next Brisket (whenever that is).

If you are needing to control the salt, the easiest way is making up your own rub without salt. Apply all the rub you want, then apply the salt separately.

I'm still kicking my own butt, out of necessity (I ran out) I made up a basic rub with brown sugar, garlic powder, red pepper and some other stuff. Didn't write it down and I don't remember what I put in it. It was the best rub I've ever used...

Hans61 · May 2016

Try throwing some lawyres in the salt and pepper mix!

GrateEggspectations · May 2016

Franklin's book (which I don't have on hand at present) indicates the amount of seasoning you should be using per lb of brisket. That's probably a good starting point and then you can adjust accordingly.

henapple · May 2016

Season the **** out of it. It's a huge chunk of meat. I've seen @sgh be anal retentive about it.... Adding seasoning as it cooks.

Under seasoned Brisket, again!

Comments

Categories