Royal Oak charcoal

jabam

Is this the best we can do on a Friday night? Talking about lump!

jabam

jabam

Hillary!!

Darby_Crenshaw

stlcharcoal said:

Darby_Crenshaw said:

Doc_Eggerton said:

Cowboy?  A few free pounds doesn't make up for plastic straps, fiberglass and plywood.

and the plywood?  Big deal. Pull it out and get over it. They do not use plywood to make charcoal. You might get a stray piece, but that's rare. And that sh!t happens to every manufacturer  

You will NEVER find a piece of plywood in our bags......I can guarantee that.  With the way the supply chain works, some charcoal companies can be sure of that.  All of our charcoal comes from slab and cord wood.

What about a rock, or metal strap, or piece of refeactory lining?

you guarantee me perfectly sized, no-rock, no-strap charcoal, and i'll buy nothing but yours from here on out

But the moment i find any of those things, all you need to do is refund me all i spent previously. 

Deal?

Darby_Crenshaw

Charcoal is charcoal. And anyone trying to tell me otherwise is either emotionally or financially invested

I can cook anything you want over anyone's charcoal

that's not bragging. I'm an idiot. We all know that. 

But i am dumb enough to know that charcoal is just carbonized wood

If someone has a lock on superior carbon, lemme know. And I'm there 

until then, it's just chevy vs ford

EDIT: broads like carbon in the crystalline form of diamonds. And they fuss over minute differences in clarity and color. Where guys **** equally about the size of lump and whether there was a rock in the bag. Both mentalities are foreign to me

DMW

Hans61

Royal Oak I've purchased one month ago (bought 5 bags) seems great, big pieces, and at 10/bucks per bag at "Walley World" has me reconsidering spending 24$ for BGE or Rockwood. (I know online if spending north of 100 its only 22 per bag)

I've bought two bags of Rockwood in the last year, and there's almost zero white smoke, truly impressive, great charcoal, if $ was no option I'd probably be all rockwood, but if $ was no option, I might have a komodo-kamado instead of an egg, oh and I probably would have bought the weber summit charcoal grill too :-)

I have to wait 10-20min approximately for the RO to burn off the white smoke before putting my meat on the grill. That said, the price difference, I'll wait for the white smoke and save $, end products are great with either/any lump; except cowboy...lol!

nolaegghead

Cowboy is my favorite lump in the whole wide world.  I love it.  I talk to it sometimes..."I love you lump...make me proud as I set you on fire and cook stuff" I say.  I will travel hundreds of miles to buy cowboy lump because it has no rival.  There is never too much foreign stuff in my lovely bags of Cowboy lump.  Anyone who disagrees with me can go f themself.

XC242

The whole lump discussion has me so confused I've just given up on using it. Turns out I've got a cheap alternative right in my backyard. I just scoop up a big armful of old needles, cones and dry branches from underneath our pine tree and throw it in the egg. Seems to work okay for me...

Focker

nolaegghead said:

Cowboy is my favorite lump in the whole wide world.  I love it.  I talk to it sometimes..."I love you lump...make me proud as I set you on fire and cook stuff" I say.  I will travel hundreds of miles to buy cowboy lump because it has no rival.  There is never too much foreign stuff in my lovely bags of Cowboy lump.  Anyone who disagrees with me can go f themself.

Cowboy = Stagnation Dogg

nolaegghead

You could take hardwood from a dog park (soaked with canine urine and the tears of lonely people) and with a tree infested with dutch elm disease, growing fungus, hosting termites, work lunchroom refrigerator mold science experiments covering it, doused endlessly with drunk person vomit after eating haggis from the local Irish pub, etc.  In fact Henapple could jerk off on it. Imagine any other horror that doesn't involve inorganic heavy metal contamination, and the carbonation process just doesn't give a sh!t.  You make charcoal.

That said, Cowboy is the best.  By far.  I'm surprised it's so affordable.  When you can find it.  DAMN YOU HOME DESPOT FOR SWITCHING BRANDS!!!!

I will fight anyone who disagrees.  Just PM me your location and I will be there to fight.

Jupiter Jim

nolaegghead said:

Cowboy is my favorite lump in the whole wide world.  I love it.  I talk to it sometimes..."I love you lump...make me proud as I set you on fire and cook stuff" I say.  I will travel hundreds of miles to buy cowboy lump because it has no rival.  There is never too much foreign stuff in my lovely bags of Cowboy lump.  Anyone who disagrees with me can go f themself.

It makes feel all warm and fuzzy when you get so poetic about lump! Thanks Man

DieselkW

whenever I find a rock in my bag of lump, I just toss it over next to the fence.

logchief

Really nice looking backyard, better than lump love.

YukonRon

DieselkW said:

whenever I find a rock in my bag of lump, I just toss it over next to the fence.

@DieselkW Love the fence. I am getting ready to pull up my old fence, installed prior to our purchase of our home. It is hideous to say the least. It will be a major reconstruction of my back yard.;

jaydub58

I have used RO for about 4 years. Like it, no complaints, will continue to use it. 
As for Home Depot "secret price increase", unless HD is now printing RO's bags for them (not), it would be RO's price increase.
They are the one who lowered the bag weight.

Biggreenpharmacist

nolaegghead said:

You could take hardwood from a dog park (soaked with canine urine and the tears of lonely people) and with a tree infested with dutch elm disease, growing fungus, hosting termites, work lunchroom refrigerator mold science experiments covering it, doused endlessly with drunk person vomit after eating haggis from the local Irish pub, etc.  In fact Henapple could jerk off on it. Imagine any other horror that doesn't involve inorganic heavy metal contamination, and the carbonation process just doesn't give a sh!t.  You make charcoal.

That said, Cowboy is the best.  By far.  I'm surprised it's so affordable.  When you can find it.  DAMN YOU HOME DESPOT FOR SWITCHING BRANDS!!!!

I will fight anyone who disagrees.  Just PM me your location and I will be there to fight.

cowboy is especially lovely for chicken wings. Reminds me of the old days when we would make a nice fire of old railroad crossties and cook chickens on sharpened pieces of switchcane, feathers and all. 

stlcharcoal

Biggreenpharmacist

@stlcharcoal have you got any news on possible RW distributer here in arkansas yet?

Jupiter Jim

flynnbob

Rockwood is all that I use now.  It is the best and I will pay for performance.

DMW

XC242

Stopped at my dealer today to resupply. Haven't used Fogo yet so I'm looking forward to giving it a go. Picked up the bags of Rockwood and heard that distinctive "tink" sound that lets me know I did the right thing in buying it. 

Would I rather spend less on RO at Wallyworld, Home Depot or Menards? Sure, but I can taste a difference in the taste of the food so I pay the extra to get lump that makes a difference for me. Some of us are just more sensitive to the taste. 

Lit

flynnbob said:

Rockwood is all that I use now.  It is the best and I will pay for performance.

I'm sorry but there are multiple choices as good or better at the rockwood price point or less. Fogo for one hands down is better all day long. Basques sugar maple is better. Wicked good is as good or better. I spent the $26 for a bag at ace and it's good but saying it's the best is just wrong.

Begger

I've started a COLLECTION of all the unburables found in RO and BGE lump.
When it hits 1lb. or more, I'm shipping it BACK to 'em.   Virtually every bag has something to add to the pile.    My last bag of BGE contained maybe 30% small to unusable sized pieces.  

Beachman

Noticed an increase in very small pieces in RO bags, enough that can restrict air flow through the round holes in the BGE grates. May be due to rough handling during shipping.

RedSkip

@stlcharcoal. Care to show a video of how your charcoal is made?  Free advertising and enough of us eggheads would love to see the process!

Tony_T

I used 2 bags of Rockwood and was happy with it, so next order was for 5 bags.  I'm on bag 3 of the 5 order, and the first 2 (of the 5 bag order) had a lot of small pieces and a lot of dust at the bottom of the bags.  Burned well, with little smoke (which I like about Rockwood), so I'm not too disappointed, but based on the reviews here I guess I was expecting more….

  

I would like to give Fogo a go next…

ColtsFan

Drove an hour today to restock. 

cfuller3

Enjoy this forum but glad I was able to see my way through the lump threads without spending any time or thought about it.  Charcoal. Lump charcoal.  From wood. Works for me.