Pork Shoulder or Brisket

KGilma2018

I'm thinking about having a little party Saturday.  8-10 people probably.  I have a 9-10 lbs Shoulder and 9lbs Brisket in the freezer.  Which one should I cook and will it be enough for that many people?  

Brisket_Fanatic

Why not cook both?

Definitely have enough pork and should have enough brisket as long as you have other sides and your not feeding the high school football team. If it were me I would do both as they both make great leftovers.

lkapigian

^^^^^^^this^^^^^ you have plenty and they both freeze well or your guests would be blessed to take you cook home

unoriginalusername

Have you cooked either before?  If yes go with whichever you like and or do both like others have said if you have an XL or L with a raised grid.  Having two large meats in a large egg will impact the cooking time from what you're used to on solo cooks. 

If you haven't done a brisket before and are planning to eat at a specific time doing both while doing your first brisket while trying to manage a deadline for being done is probably a little over ambitious 

KGilma2018

I've only had the egg about a month.  I've cooked a small brisket, this would be the first pork shoulder.  It's a large egg btw.

SonVolt

That is gorgeous. How well can tile be expected to hold up in the elements? 

EDIT: Oops, wrong thread. 

pgprescott

In the words of the illustrious Dion Sanders “both”!

lousubcap

Wherever you land start the fridge defrost now.  I'm guessing based on the brisket weight that it is a flat??  If you had success with your prior brisket cook then this one would be just scaled up recognizing the "friggin cow drives the cook. "
The shoulder is a much less demanding cook. 
Regarding quantity of food-for the pork figure about 50-60% yield from raw to cooked weight so 10 lbs raw will give you around 5- 6 lbs cooked.  Figure 1/2 lb /person you would have 10-12 servings.  You can use the same numbers with your brisket.  FWIW-

lkapigian

SonVolt said:

That is gorgeous. How well can tile be expected to hold up in the elements? 

EDIT: Oops, wrong thread. 

Ha, and I was looking for pictures of tile

KGilma2018

lousubcap said:

Wherever you land start the fridge defrost now.  I'm guessing based on the brisket weight that it is a flat??  If you had success with your prior brisket cook then this one would be just scaled up recognizing the "friggin cow drives the cook. "
The shoulder is a much less demanding cook. 
Regarding quantity of food-for the pork figure about 50-60% yield from raw to cooked weight so 10 lbs raw will give you around 5- 6 lbs cooked.  Figure 1/2 lb /person you would have 10-12 servings.  You can use the same numbers with your brisket.  FWIW-

I'm leaning towards the shoulder just because I haven't done one, yet.  My brisket was a success but I'd like to try something new.  I'm not opposed to doing both but I've only had the egg for a month and don't have all the accessories yet like a 2nd grid.  Could both fit side by side on a large?

lousubcap

I am guessing based on the weights that you could likely get them both on one grid but you would have to do a lot of foil protecting as there would be a lot over-hanging your heat deflector.  The drip pan containment would present a bit of a challenge as well.  About the quickest way to a second level cook is to drink three aluminum canned beers and save the cans-then buy a 17" weber grid.  Place the cans on your BGE grid and the weber on top.  FWIW-

KGilma2018

lousubcap said:

I am guessing based on the weights that you could likely get them both on one grid but you would have to do a lot of foil protecting as there would be a lot over-hanging your heat deflector.  The drip pan containment would present a bit of a challenge as well.  About the quickest way to a second level cook is to drink three aluminum canned beers and save the cans-then buy a 17" weber grid.  Place the cans on your BGE grid and the weber on top.  FWIW-

Thanks for the simple suggestion on the raised grid.  I will do that if I decide to make both.

KGilma2018

I've decided to go with just the shoulder.  I want to eat between 5-6pm.  I'm thinking if I get it on the egg by 6am at 250-275 I should be done around 3pm.  Then FTC until it's time to pull.  Sound good, or should I get it going earlier?

KGilma2018

Also, when I see people say 225 - 1.5-2hr or 1 hr @ 275 per pound, are they taking the stall into consideration too?  Now, I know those numbers are just estimates and every cook and egg will be a little different. Just curious.

unoriginalusername

KGilma2018 said:

I've decided to go with just the shoulder.  I want to eat between 5-6pm.  I'm thinking if I get it on the egg by 6am at 250-275 I should be done around 3pm.  Then FTC until it's time to pull.  Sound good, or should I get it going earlier?

I like your plan, wisdom over gambling. I would smoke at 272 and spray with apple cider vinegar / apple juice or hot sauce (I personally cold smoke whiskey or apple cider vinegar for use in my sprays) every 45 min for a spritz until IT reaches 160 and the bark looks amazing. Then I’d wrap it in butcher paper until down. 

Let rest for 30, wrap in foil and then FTC for a few hours befoe pulling and serving 

KGilma2018

unoriginalusername said:

KGilma2018 said:

I've decided to go with just the shoulder.  I want to eat between 5-6pm.  I'm thinking if I get it on the egg by 6am at 250-275 I should be done around 3pm.  Then FTC until it's time to pull.  Sound good, or should I get it going earlier?

I like your plan, wisdom over gambling. I would smoke at 272 and spray with apple cider vinegar / apple juice or hot sauce (I personally cold smoke whiskey or apple cider vinegar for use in my sprays) every 45 min for a spritz until IT reaches 160 and the bark looks amazing. Then I’d wrap it in butcher paper until down. 

Let rest for 30, wrap in foil and then FTC for a few hours befoe pulling and serving 

I like the 50/50 apple juice / vinegar and spray every hour or so.  

unoriginalusername

KGilma2018 said:

unoriginalusername said:

KGilma2018 said:

I've decided to go with just the shoulder.  I want to eat between 5-6pm.  I'm thinking if I get it on the egg by 6am at 250-275 I should be done around 3pm.  Then FTC until it's time to pull.  Sound good, or should I get it going earlier?

I like your plan, wisdom over gambling. I would smoke at 272 and spray with apple cider vinegar / apple juice or hot sauce (I personally cold smoke whiskey or apple cider vinegar for use in my sprays) every 45 min for a spritz until IT reaches 160 and the bark looks amazing. Then I’d wrap it in butcher paper until down. 

Let rest for 30, wrap in foil and then FTC for a few hours befoe pulling and serving 

I like the 50/50 apple juice / vinegar and spray every hour or so.  

Good plan. For fun some time try cold smoking the spray for an added extra Smokey bark

KGilma2018

I'm about 4 hours in and now the temp on the bone side has dropped from 152 to 139 (flame boss probe).  The other side with my maverick is still rising up to 158 now.   Any idea what's going on?   Did I hit the stall? 

steel_egg

KGilma2018 said:

I'm about 4 hours in and now the temp on the bone side has dropped from 152 to 139 (flame boss probe).  The other side with my maverick is still rising up to 158 now.   Any idea what's going on?   Did I hit the stall? 

Not sure if you are in the stall yet but I doubt it will be done by 3 if you’re on east coast time. I’d bump up to 300-325 to push thru the stall. I don’t the long drawn out low and slows anymore. No noticeable difference in my opinion.  FWIW. 

KGilma2018

I think the probe may be bad.   It's keeps dropping.  Now its 122f.  Other one is up to 167.

KGilma2018

Put it on at 5am pulled it at 2:30pm.  The temp probe on the brand new FB is defective

KGilma2018

Not sure why this didn't work from my cell phone, lets try it again.  Put it on at 5am, and pulled it at 2:30.  The temp probe on the FB is defective.  I'm returning it today for a new one.  I pulled the pork at 200* then FTC until 5:30 when it was time to eat.  It was still 167* at that point.  The bone fell right out.  A kings Hawaiian bun, some homemade slaw, and a little Famous Dave's devil spit sauce, it was delicious!  Even though the FB probe was defective that thing is awesome.  I can't wait to use it again.