4.5 lb. sirloin tip roast

Unknown

Is it possible to cook a sirloin tip roast on the egg that comes out very tender or is this piece of meat better for oven braising

Bacchus

I don't have your answer, but if "oven braising" is the key, then you could still do it on the egg. If you don't already have one, you can pick up a Cast Iron Dutch Oven at Walmart for $25-$40. In fact, this sounds pretty darn good. I might have to do that......

civil eggineer

Guaranteed it will be better on the egg. Since sirloin is generally lower in fat marbling, I would cook around 400 dome temp until internal meat temp was around 140 then pull and rest in cooler.

Old Salt

A week or so ago someone posted about cooking an huge sirloin tip roast if my ancient memory serves me.