Minimax, Small, or Medium?

Mattman3969

You need a 2XL !!

bgebrent

Mattman3969 said:

bgebrent said:

Logic is on the side of a medium or MM. 

what is the logic ?   Maybe I need a medium because I already have the adult size mm. 😎

The mini, while mighty, has no territory.  Unless you only want 2 hotdogs...  seriously, it’s a great cooker.  The medium is under-touted and the egg I wish I had.  Good real-estate and portability.  If you could text Nichole I’d appreciate it.  Truth:  I own a MM, a L and an XL.  Use them all. The MM the most.  Logic is on the side of function.  Form follows function.  Hence the obvious vote for a little more cooking space.

Theophan

I have a Medium and a Large, and I LOVE my Medium, and cook in it way more often than the Large, but it's usually just me and my wife.  I've never had a Small or a MiniMax, so I can't compare, but I really love my Medium.  And I'm leery of the MiniMax because it's so shallow.  Great for portability, but if you don't need it to be portable, seems like a bad idea to me!  But as @stlcharcoalsaid, there are SO many more accessories for the Large, if you like that sort of thing.  I can't see the advantage of the Small over the Medium, myself -- just seems too small, a lot of the time.

bgebrent

Theophan said:

I have a Medium and a Large, and I LOVE my Medium, and cook in it way more often than the Large, but it's usually just me and my wife.  I've never had a Small or a MiniMax, so I can't compare, but I really love my Medium.  And I'm leery of the MiniMax because it's so shallow.  Great for portability, but if you don't need it to be portable, seems like a bad idea to me!  But as @stlcharcoalsaid, there are SO many more accessories for the Large, if you like that sort of thing.  I can't see the advantage of the Small over the Medium, myself -- just seems too small, a lot of the time.

Confirmation 

lousubcap

I thought confirmation was a religious deal...

cookingdude555

As an owner of the medium, small, mini max, and mini - the medium is my favorite over the rest. When I had just a large and a small, I thought the small was best. Then I bought my medium from @Grandpas Grub, and that changed my opinion.  But I did use the mini max today, and it’s a fabulous cooker too. 

Calmdowneight

Thanks folks! I think after considering everything, I will just stick with the XL and maybe order a set of the recommended L angles from ceramic grill store to divide the firebox for smaller cooks.

Theophan

Calmdowneight said:

... I will just stick with the XL and maybe order a set of the recommended L angles from ceramic grill store to divide the firebox for smaller cooks.

Very sensible!  I am happy to have two Eggs (Medium and Large), but if I already had an XL, gosh, it'd be hard to justify buying another Egg for smaller cooks.  Those dividing brackets look like a great idea!

Calmdowneight

Theophan said:

Calmdowneight said:

... I will just stick with the XL and maybe order a set of the recommended L angles from ceramic grill store to divide the firebox for smaller cooks.

Very sensible!  I am happy to have two Eggs (Medium and Large), but if I already had an XL, gosh, it'd be hard to justify buying another Egg for smaller cooks.  Those dividing brackets look like a great idea!

I think they’re just what I need! I hope they work as well as advertised.

RalphieBoy

Buy a Small

DoubleEgger

Theophan said:

Calmdowneight said:

... I will just stick with the XL and maybe order a set of the recommended L angles from ceramic grill store to divide the firebox for smaller cooks.

Very sensible!  I am happy to have two Eggs (Medium and Large), but if I already had an XL, gosh, it'd be hard to justify buying another Egg for smaller cooks.  

Over the past four and a half years, I’ve paid for my medium in lump savings over the XL. 

cookingdude555

DoubleEgger said:

Theophan said:

Calmdowneight said:

... I will just stick with the XL and maybe order a set of the recommended L angles from ceramic grill store to divide the firebox for smaller cooks.

Very sensible!  I am happy to have two Eggs (Medium and Large), but if I already had an XL, gosh, it'd be hard to justify buying another Egg for smaller cooks.  

Over the past four and a half years, I’ve paid for my medium in lump savings over the XL. 

@DoubleEgger, I've always wondered, do you still only have two eggs?  The handle suggests so, but in the 10 years of having my eggs, my collection has grown dramatically, as is usually the case for many eggers.  Just wondering if you need to change your name to TripleEgger or higher.

blind99

I have a large and a small.  Wish I had XL and medium.  Of course then I'd also get a large and a small.  And a minimax that could look up to them as it grows up.  


Seriously, though.  The small is a great little grill, easy to use for quick weeknight cooks for 4-5 people.  I'm not crazy about it as a smoker - holds one pork butt, airflow isn't as good as my large. 

DoubleEgger

cookingdude555 said:

DoubleEgger said:

Theophan said:

Calmdowneight said:

... I will just stick with the XL and maybe order a set of the recommended L angles from ceramic grill store to divide the firebox for smaller cooks.

Very sensible!  I am happy to have two Eggs (Medium and Large), but if I already had an XL, gosh, it'd be hard to justify buying another Egg for smaller cooks.  

Over the past four and a half years, I’ve paid for my medium in lump savings over the XL. 

@DoubleEgger, I've always wondered, do you still only have two eggs?  The handle suggests so, but in the 10 years of having my eggs, my collection has grown dramatically, as is usually the case for many eggers.  Just wondering if you need to change your name to TripleEgger or higher.

I have successfully resisted the urge to buy another egg. Between the XL and the Medium, I really don’t need anything else. I think my XL is 8yrs old and the medium a “rode hard and put up wet” 4 yrs. 

cookingdude555

You have done well!