Big Green Egg - EGGhead Forum - The Ultimate Cooking Experience...
We hope everyone enjoyed their Fourth of July weekend and is excited for more warm weather grilling! This week, we’ll be making these two burgers: Stuffed Portobello Mushroom and Caribbean Chicken, and also eating lots of these Ice Cream Sandwiches in honor of National Ice Cream Month! It's time to think about getting out to one of the many #EGGfests around the country - see a list here

The "bad and ugly"

edited November -1 in EggHead Forum
Frozen Salmon. Need I say more?[p]I live in Washington and have always eaten fresh salmon. Either caught by me or from the store.[p]Last year we went on a trip and I have a freezer full of some beautiful fish.'s fishy. I should have known better.[p]Tonight, I did this fish at 250 degrees for 1.5 hours...looked very promising, but I was disappointed. It was moist and even had good texture, but it was "fishy" [p]I may just thaw more if it out and put it in a Little Chief smoker to try to see if I can "smoke-over" the fishiness. this is the best way to get the most smokiness, I think. Any other ideas?[p]Thanks![p]CIMG0979.jpg[p][p][p]


  • ab ovoab ovo Posts: 67
    mukl,[p]Try marinating in a marinade that contains some lemon. Lemons contain a chemical that neutralizes the chemical that produces the fishy taste. Do you have any clue why it is so fishy? Were the fish filleted promptly after they were caught?
  • irishrogirishrog Posts: 375
    were the fish well protected in the freezer, or did they get a bit of frost bite.
    Have they been in the freezer a long time?
    Were they defrosted very long before they were cooked, and were they kept in the fridge while defrosting?
    Many things can cause fish to spoil quickly, but you should not be able to smell fish from very fresh fish, once it starts to smell fishy then it has started to deteriorate.[p]

  • gdenbygdenby Posts: 4,168
    mukl,[p]Where I live in the midwest, really fresh fish is hard to come by (even if self caught, is likely to be chemical tainted) and so I'm used to "fishy" fish. As ab-ovo said, lemon juice on the fish before hand reduces the fishi-ness. Also, rosemary seems to somewhat neutralize it, and add a counterbalance flavor.

  • mukl, This is what works for me when there is some "fishy" consideration. Current spousal unit will not touch anything that is "fishy", but loves when I cook fish, as below: Note that if the fish is "spoiled"...nothing will help.[p]1st: Rinse fish briefly w/ Vinegar, yep, plain 'ol vinegar...just a mild acid wash...this will help get rid of any exterior fish odor/taste problems[p]2nd: Whilst Cooking >>> Apply lime (or lemon) juice to your taste...we use a lot.. I do NOT marinate w/ the lime juice, just cook.. This does not mask any fishyness, just removes same & lends add'l flavour...Of course, you can apply any rub of your choice to taste...[p]This works for me if I am grilling fish or slow-smoking...Good Luck!

  • MetalheadMetalhead Posts: 668
    I just lurked both of your posts...the good and the bad and ugly....say you got the flu? maybe them taste buds of yours ain't working too good. and God forgive if you gave it to the misses and that's why she says it's fishy

Sign In or Register to comment.