Big Green Egg - EGGhead Forum - The Ultimate Cooking Experience...
We’re so close to Thanksgiving that we can taste it and we’re ready to help you prepare the most delicious Thanksgiving feast you’ve ever cooked! Check out our Turkey Cheat Sheet for turkey tips, our Thanksgiving page for turkey recipes, and our Holiday Entertaining Publication for all other Thanksgiving needs to help you make this the best Thanksgiving yet! PS. Don’t forget about breakfast Thanksgiving morning either!

Big Green Egg headquarters has moved - come visit our new showroom and check out the museum and culinary center too! 3786 DeKalb Technology Parkway, Atlanta, GA 30340.

whole pork shoulder (New Yourk Shoulder)

I'd like to thank Elder Ward for his wonderful instructions on the North Carolina Pork Butt. I was very impressed with the outcome and so excited about this new discovery that I want to attempt a whole pork shoulder for Superbowl Sunday, which includes the picnic shoulder and the butt connected. My butcher tells me he can get one that weighs 16-17lbs. My question is, (I am hoping that Elder Ward is reading this) Has anyone ever attempted this on the BGE and if so, could he/she (I'm from California, so I have to be politically correct) please share the results with me? [p]Thank you, all.


  • Rick Windham,[p]I'm in late and yes reading your post. Thanks for all the nice things you have said. Yes I have done that much and more really you will need to do nothing different execpt this: If the pieces of meat differ in size more than a few pounds and you have but one probe mesaure the smaller one. When it is done transfer the probe to the larger one when you remove the smaller. You may find that both are done at the same time but if not let the first set for 15-20 min. then shread or pull and cover until bigger one is done. If you are using all the meat at once just mix both up and serve. I use to do the larger piece as the monitor piece but the smaller one seemed drier so I quite doing that. :)[p]Posted from soggy Camarillo, CA aaaaah winter at last.[p]Elder Ward[p]
  • Tim MTim M Posts: 2,410
    Rick Windham,[p]I don't see that getting the whole shoulder, still with both pieces connected, will be any advantage - more likely the opposite would be true. The taste of the picnic will be slightly different than the butt - but once cooked and sauced you will nnot be able to tell any difference. As Elder said, they will cook differently (one has a huge bone that speeds cooking somewhat) and reach 200 at different times. Have fun with it - [p]Tim
  • I've done two large butts and a picnic together (3 pieces). The picnic yielded less (% edible meat) than the butts, cost more per pound because I couldn't get it from Sams or Costco, and had a different, but not better, texture and flavor. I prefer to do two or three butts, and won't do another picnic.

  • Elder Ward,[p]Thank you very much for your quick response and feedback. I'm sure all my friends pulling for the Rams will appreciate it. I understand there's a Tennessee style of barbecuing, but I hope it's not lamb that they eat.[p]Much appreciated,
    Rick Windham

  • George,[p]Thanks for your response. I'm trying the whole pork shoulder mainly for aesthetic reasons, but I agree the pork butt is the better part of the meat.[p]Rick

  • Tim M,[p]Thanks for your feedback. I agree that the pork butt is probably the better part of the meat.[p]Rick

Sign In or Register to comment.