Welcome to the EGGhead Forum - a great place to visit and packed with tips and EGGspert advice! You can also join the conversation and get more information and amazing kamado recipes by following Big Green Egg to Experience our World of Flavor™ at:
Want to see how the EGG is made? Click to Watch
Facebook | Twitter | Instagram | Pinterest | Youtube | Vimeo
Share your photos by tagging us and using the hashtag #BigGreenEgg.
Share your photos by tagging us and using the hashtag #BigGreenEgg.
Want to see how the EGG is made? Click to Watch
Mickey Z’s Big Marcs - I cooked some’en too
Zippylip
Posts: 4,768
Keep’m com’n JL:
Unlike last week’s McRib, Big Macs are serious bin-ness, love’m, I know of no other set of humble
(if not suspect) ingredients that yield such a symphony of flavor. That said, I hate the nastiness
factor of the industry so I can’t remember the last time I had a real one. A few years ago, I decided to recreate one at home.
The Key: abandon your natural instincts to put the best burger on a plate you can, this will not lend itself to authenticity. For example, you will be tempted to use a nice-sized burger patty, which would of course be wrong; you may also want to use fresh cut onions, this too would be a mistake; & when selecting pickles, you will naturally seek out the tastiest, crunchiest, most vibrant looking pickles available, again, an error. There is a moderately counterintuitive process involved in dumbing down the food, which is what you have to do to achieve the flavor of a Big Mac.
Legal Disclaimer: I am not a licensed Big Macateer, so we just call them Big Marcs, for after all, like bill, Pat & Steven, I do strike an imposing physical massiveness :laugh: :laugh: , although I do not have Pat’s violent temper :evil: , for I understand that he will kick the crap out of anyone so long as they are semi-conscious/rip-snort’n-drunk & securely held down by Big’un.
To make, just follow the jingle that was burned into your brain over 30 years ago:
2 All Beef Patties: I use any cheap cut of steak on sale & grind it up, form into golf-ball sized pieces for squishing (the patties are only 2 or 3 ounces each);
Special Sauce: when I first made the Big Marc, I thought mixing Ketchup, Mayo & Sweet Relish would pretty much do the trick, but to be sure, I searched the net to find a recipe, & to my surprise, most called for French Dressing, Miracle Whip & other stuff which just sounded puke-inducing to me
, so I went with my gut & found that above combination tastes like the real spooge so that’s what I go with;
Lettuce: Iceburg lettuce cut into very small pieces (for extra authenticity, let it wilt for a day or so);
Cheese: I’ve tried Velveeta slices & Orange American Cheese, they both seem to duplicate the flavor;
Pickles: look for the lowest priced, lowest quality, dead looking store brand pickle slices available;
Onions: I have always been convinced that dehydrated onions are re-hydrated on site, how else do they get those super tiny onion bit looking things they put on the burger? I refuse to reconstitute anything, so to duplicate the look and flavor, I start with a real onion sliced very thin on a mandolin. The key is to then soak the slices in water for an hour or so, dry, then cut into very small onion bits (this will remove most of the flavor & result it that dehydrated/re-hydrated ‘hint-o-onion’ flavor that is accomplished so well in the real deal);
On a
Sesame Seed Bun: For each Big Marc you will need 2 buns. Cut the top off of one of the tops to form the ‘club’ section (feed the cut off tops and bottoms to the birds);
To cook, smash the meat down with a spatula so it’s about a 1/4 inch thick & cook on a griddle or cast iron pan (it’s raining today so we are cook’n on porch mini, for that I cover the grid with foil and cut a slit in the middle so as not to restrict air flow), and because you do not want any smoke flavor whatsoever, cook with only well pre-burned lump. Melt cheese on, assemble & enjoy with french fries & a coke (or in my case a beer).
This will taste like the real thing except for the flavor added by a teenager with questionable hygiene & standards:














And this is Ali Approved:
Unlike last week’s McRib, Big Macs are serious bin-ness, love’m, I know of no other set of humble
(if not suspect) ingredients that yield such a symphony of flavor. That said, I hate the nastiness
factor of the industry so I can’t remember the last time I had a real one. A few years ago, I decided to recreate one at home.
The Key: abandon your natural instincts to put the best burger on a plate you can, this will not lend itself to authenticity. For example, you will be tempted to use a nice-sized burger patty, which would of course be wrong; you may also want to use fresh cut onions, this too would be a mistake; & when selecting pickles, you will naturally seek out the tastiest, crunchiest, most vibrant looking pickles available, again, an error. There is a moderately counterintuitive process involved in dumbing down the food, which is what you have to do to achieve the flavor of a Big Mac.
Legal Disclaimer: I am not a licensed Big Macateer, so we just call them Big Marcs, for after all, like bill, Pat & Steven, I do strike an imposing physical massiveness :laugh: :laugh: , although I do not have Pat’s violent temper :evil: , for I understand that he will kick the crap out of anyone so long as they are semi-conscious/rip-snort’n-drunk & securely held down by Big’un.
To make, just follow the jingle that was burned into your brain over 30 years ago:
2 All Beef Patties: I use any cheap cut of steak on sale & grind it up, form into golf-ball sized pieces for squishing (the patties are only 2 or 3 ounces each);
Special Sauce: when I first made the Big Marc, I thought mixing Ketchup, Mayo & Sweet Relish would pretty much do the trick, but to be sure, I searched the net to find a recipe, & to my surprise, most called for French Dressing, Miracle Whip & other stuff which just sounded puke-inducing to me
, so I went with my gut & found that above combination tastes like the real spooge so that’s what I go with;Lettuce: Iceburg lettuce cut into very small pieces (for extra authenticity, let it wilt for a day or so);
Cheese: I’ve tried Velveeta slices & Orange American Cheese, they both seem to duplicate the flavor;
Pickles: look for the lowest priced, lowest quality, dead looking store brand pickle slices available;
Onions: I have always been convinced that dehydrated onions are re-hydrated on site, how else do they get those super tiny onion bit looking things they put on the burger? I refuse to reconstitute anything, so to duplicate the look and flavor, I start with a real onion sliced very thin on a mandolin. The key is to then soak the slices in water for an hour or so, dry, then cut into very small onion bits (this will remove most of the flavor & result it that dehydrated/re-hydrated ‘hint-o-onion’ flavor that is accomplished so well in the real deal);
On a
Sesame Seed Bun: For each Big Marc you will need 2 buns. Cut the top off of one of the tops to form the ‘club’ section (feed the cut off tops and bottoms to the birds);
To cook, smash the meat down with a spatula so it’s about a 1/4 inch thick & cook on a griddle or cast iron pan (it’s raining today so we are cook’n on porch mini, for that I cover the grid with foil and cut a slit in the middle so as not to restrict air flow), and because you do not want any smoke flavor whatsoever, cook with only well pre-burned lump. Melt cheese on, assemble & enjoy with french fries & a coke (or in my case a beer).
This will taste like the real thing except for the flavor added by a teenager with questionable hygiene & standards:














And this is Ali Approved:
happy in the hut
West Chester Pennsylvania
West Chester Pennsylvania
Comments
-
Looks good. And from what I have read, soon you won't be able to get 2 slices of cheese from McDonalds anymore so why not make at home. Did you toast the buns?
-
i too love the ubiquitous big mac. . . have since they first came out when i was in high school (cost all of $.60 in the beginning!!). ..
your effort looks great.. ..thanks for sharing!!! -
Freakin Classic! Big Marcs are now on the menu!
-
The special sauce looks pretty close to the real thing.
Nice pictorial.
GG -
The end result looks great! You did over pickle. Now a days, you only get 1 pickle per Big Mac. There is a recession ya know. :S :S
LC says you are right on with the sauce(Russian dressing) and dehydrated onions. I want to know, did you steam your buns?
Could you do that with Bubbacakes? hmmmmmmmmYou must master temp, smoke, and time to achive moisture, taste, and texture! Visit www.bubbatim.com for BRISKET HELP -
His buns have been toasted for yers! :evil: :evil:You must master temp, smoke, and time to achive moisture, taste, and texture! Visit www.bubbatim.com for BRISKET HELP
-
I did not read that, what is that all about? I did very lightly toast them.happy in the hut
West Chester Pennsylvania -
Too, too funny! I never did form a passion of the "BM", however was a big fan of the plain old Micky D's Cheeseburger...classic garbage food flavor that it tough to replicate. Looks like you've throoughly researched and nailed it. And if the kids will eat it, so much the better than the real thing!
-
I am sorry to say those look pretty good! LOL fast food sends me right in to a migraine in about 20 minutes after eating it so I haven't had one of those in awhile. I might just have to do those for dinner tomorrow night. It sure looks like a lot of work !
-
Steam, huh, that may be the ticket next time, I have always lightly toasted them but something did seem off about that, guess I'll have to break out the steamer next time Big Marcs are on the menuhappy in the hut
West Chester Pennsylvania -
That is too cool. Excellent writeup and photos.
I love it. I'm not gonna do it, but I love it.
Reminds me of the Egg McFatties from sometime early last year. I think TRex and/or RTD started this trend.
-
that is beautiful. your creative writing is only surpassed by your creative and masterful eggin. that looks like a fest food if there ever was one .
i am starting to feel like a slacker.
sei un sorprendente chef -
Looks surprisingly almost good enough to eat Zippy
:woohoo: -
grazie per il complimento Guglielmohappy in the hut
West Chester Pennsylvania -
Hey Max, now I know how old you are :laugh:happy in the hut
West Chester Pennsylvania -
I promise the Big Marc will not give you a migraine, drive on down here & I'll make you a stack of them & you'll see
happy in the hut
West Chester Pennsylvania -
you are most welcome.. eggin no time to translate on i-google.. hell i can barely speak english ..
:laugh: :laugh: -
what the H is i-google :huh:happy in the hut
West Chester Pennsylvania -
Their double cheeseburger is going to one slice of cheese on the dollar menu and will be raised to $1.20. Cost too much I guess. Think it was CNBC I read that on.
-
-
that's interesting, I have been reading a lot of similar things about all food products. The latest tact by many food producers is to reduce the size of the product ever so slightly but keep the price the same, supposed to trick us into thinking prices aren't going up, the most obvious one I can think of is the new 1.5 Quart container of icecream, damn thing looks like a 1/2 Gallon if you are not paying attentionhappy in the hut
West Chester Pennsylvania -
Yep. 100 calorie packs the same way. I have also noticed Panera (not sure if you have one there) bagels are about 25% smaller.
-
I have one right up the street, they have pretty good ciabata bread, great for the panini press; if you have not tried this one give it a go: Grab a large ciabata, cut about 1/2 inch off the top, then cut it into 2 pieces for the panino, spread goat cheese on one half & cover with a thin layer of imported Mortadella, then saturate the other half with olive oil, pop on the press for a few minutes, unbelievable
happy in the hut
West Chester Pennsylvania -
I remember McDonalds quarterback promo. Big Mac for $1 and get a quarter back.
Walt -
Just looked on Wikipedia, it says the Big Mac's burgers are 1.6 ounces, even smaller than my estimated 2 to 3 ounces, damn, it is hard to make a 2 ounce burger as it is & keep it from falling apart, makes you wonder what they put in there to keep it together :huh:happy in the hut
West Chester Pennsylvania -
I'm sorry, Zippy, this is just wrong.
It reminds me of that scene in Star Wars where Darth Vader tries to convince Luke to turn his talents over to the Dark Side . -
Ok Zipp I missed this post earler. You have WAY, WAY to much time on your hands! :laugh: Good thing you do what you do cause I figure Mc Donalds will have a whole team of lawyers at your door step by 9:00 am your time!
-
JL, you are right, I am off from work this week so you’ll have to endure another 5 days of my long-winded nonsense :laugh: (that is if you choose to click on my posts), as for the Micky-D lawyers, I’ll be here at 9am for their arrival, & after they spend a couple hours in my kitchen eat’n, drink’n & wrapp’n with me, they’ll forget all about that silliness :silly: that sent them here in the first place -happy in the hut
West Chester Pennsylvania
Categories
- All Categories
- 184K EggHead Forum
- 16.1K Forum List
- 461 EGGtoberfest
- 1.9K Forum Feedback
- 10.5K Off Topic
- 2.4K EGG Table Forum
- 1 Rules & Disclaimer
- 9.2K Cookbook
- 15 Valentines Day
- 118 Holiday Recipes
- 348 Appetizers
- 521 Baking
- 2.5K Beef
- 90 Desserts
- 167 Lamb
- 2.4K Pork
- 1.5K Poultry
- 33 Salads and Dressings
- 322 Sauces, Rubs, Marinades
- 548 Seafood
- 175 Sides
- 122 Soups, Stews, Chilis
- 40 Vegetarian
- 103 Vegetables
- 315 Health
- 293 Weight Loss Forum

