Welcome to the EGGhead Forum - a great place to visit and packed with tips and EGGspert advice! You can also join the conversation and get more information and amazing kamado recipes by following Big Green Egg to Experience our World of Flavor™ at:
Facebook  |  Twitter  |  Instagram  |  Pinterest  |  Youtube  |  Vimeo
Share your photos by tagging us and using the hashtag #BigGreenEgg.

Want to see how the EGG is made? Click to Watch

Brinkman Smoker???

meathead
meathead Posts: 2
edited November -0001 in EggHead Forum
Good news -heading up to Maine for a weekend with the guy's. I'm in charge of cooking the ribs.

Bad news - I have to use a Brinkman vertical charcoal smoker.

I have never used one of these. Anyone have experience with this unit? Any tricks, tips or watchouts you can pass along?

Thanks,
Tim

Comments

  • Gunnar
    Gunnar Posts: 2,307
    Never used one....does your handle go back to "All in the Family"?
    LBGE      Katy (Houston) TX
  • gdenby
    gdenby Posts: 6,239
    The last cooker I had before getting the Egg was a Brinkman. I haven't looked recently, but I'll suppose the design hasn't changed much.

    The main problem was that it was extremely difficult to keep going long enough for ribs. Expect to foil, not just for tenderness, but to speed the cook up.

    It tends to burn hot, because there isn't good air flow control, and, as I recall, both top sections have to be removed to add more charcoal. Because it was such a fuss taking it apart to add more chimneys of briquettes, I usually just cooked for the 3.5 hours that a full load lasted, and the lowest temp was around 300.

    So lo-n-slo was not quite possible. However, for faster cooks it was not to bad. With frequent basting, chicken turned out pretty well.

    You can use sand in the water pan if you like. That way you don't need check to see if the pan needs refilling. But I'm not sure which is more unpleasant at the end, a bucket of greasy water to dump, or a pile of gooey sand.
  • I had a Brinkman before my egg too. I agree with all of your comments. Temp control was difficult. I had no idea what temp I was cooking at as the thermometer on mine just said Cool-Ideal-Hot. Never calibrated it. Always tried to keep it in the Ideal zone and it wasn't easy. It was great for chicken or a roast beef but I found it difficult for ribs for the reasons you suggest. I stopped filling the pan with water after I put my fire out by dumping it on the hot coals after burning my fingers while setting it in place for the umpteenth time. Despite all of this, it worked pretty well for what it was. I'd be happy to try one again for a week or so.
    Paul
  • Clay Q
    Clay Q Posts: 4,486
    You'll be ok. If it's a water smoker, should be a side door on the thing for adding water to the water pan and charcoal to the grate. Use a second pair of tongs for adding extra charcoal during the cook, smokin wood, and a watering can with a long spout(sprinkler head off)for adding to the water pan.

    When you start off, load'er up good with charcoal but only use 1/2 a pan full of water. Add more water as it evaporates, check with a flashlight if its hard to see in. This way the charcoal does not need to burn as hot to get steam and proper dome temp up to the ribs.

    Now if its an offset-vertical smoker, if you can, place a pan of water somewhere between the charcoal and meat, even a small pan of water will help keep the meat from drying out.

    Set up the cooker out of the wind, have a cooler loaded with ice and beer, gin, vermouth, olives and you should be all set. 3-1-1 method for spare ribs, 2-1-1 for baby backs at 250 dome is what I would do. (should have a therm in the dome, I hope)
    One last thing....leather gloves, gotta have them.
    Good luck and have fun!

    P.S. Your gonna miss your egg big time.
  • gdenby
    gdenby Posts: 6,239
    The Brinkman gives good results for a very basic smoker. Thinking about it, if you had 2, it would be easy to transfer a batch of ribs from one to the other as the fire went out on the first.

    My recollection was that the side door was positioned so that you could only drop a few briquettes past the water pan into the coals to replenish without taking it apart. The heap of ashes got to be pretty high, tho'.
  • TomM24
    TomM24 Posts: 1,366
    I used one before my egg. I never had trouble with it running hot but it requires alot of attention to keep the temp steady. I would start with a chimmney full of charcoal and then add more as it dies down. Mine had a adjustable vent on the top so you try to control the temp with it . Eventually you will get to the point where there is so much ash you will have to add lit coals from a chimney
  • Bacchus
    Bacchus Posts: 6,019
    Cut off the cord and load the bottom with lump.
  • I wasn't much of a griller/smoker before I purchased my BGE. The mess and trouble using all those different grills which eventually rusted away in my back yard, for anything other than steaks or hamburgers, just didn't seem to be worth it.

    I have come to realize that many of our forum members began their grilling hobby with all kinds of different cookers with different gizmos and gadgets to make them work, and after they discovered the BGE they found Utopia (as did I).

    I've got it made! I thank my lucky stars for this forum (and many of you greeneggers), and all the "learn-the-hard-way" experience you make available to me. You guys are the best.
  • I used a Brinkmann electric smoker for years and it made terrific ribs and was very easy to operate....put the rub on the ribs, put them in a vertical rack, put some wood chunks in the bottom of the smoker, plug it in, come back in 3 1/2 hours and get the delicious ribs out and eat 'em....it maintained a constant 225 degrees without checking anything other than the circuit for the plug on the back porch because it would trip a circuit breaker if someone pluged in a hair dryer in either bathroom while the smoker was pluged in....you will be fine, have a great time.
  • fishlessman
    fishlessman Posts: 34,584
    ive never done this but i think i would cook those ribs in the egg with the 311 method skipping the last step and vacuum pack and maybe even freeze. reheat over a regular open grill with a thinned out basting sauce. i wouldnt want to learn a new cooker and be put on the spot cooking ribs.
    fukahwee maine

    you can lead a fish to water but you can not make him drink it
  • I burned out several ECBS (el cheapo Brinkman smokers) before I wised up and went to ceramics. Everything thats posted is correct and you can successfully cook almost anything on one.

    One word of caution however. If you use the water pan and it runs DRY, be VERY careful adding more water. I was going to slowly add more water to a dry (and very hot) pan. The boiling water and steam carried accumulated fat to the fire resulting in a flash back that relieved me of my eyebrows.

    Other than that, follow the previous posts and you can be successful.
  • how come you can"t take your egg with you?
  • sirlancealot,

    My egg is a large and it lives on my back deck. Too much hassle to take it along.

    Worse yet, it is a "Meco" smoker I have to deal with. It is a glorified charcoal grill.

    It's like a piece of tin foil shaped like a smoker!!!!!

    Wish me luck
    Tim