Welcome to the EGGhead Forum - a great place to visit and packed with tips and EGGspert advice! You can also join the conversation and get more information and amazing kamado recipes by following Big Green Egg to Experience our World of Flavor™ at:
Facebook  |  Twitter  |  Instagram  |  Pinterest  |  Youtube  |  Vimeo
Share your photos by tagging us and using the hashtag #BigGreenEgg.

Want to see how the EGG is made? Click to Watch

My new egg thoughts (long)

Well, my new large Egg was delivered on Friday. I cranked her up Friday night and the only times the coals weren't hot were overnight Friday and then Sunday evening. Monday night she finally cooled down. Here are my thoughts and menu...I'll welcome any comments and/or advice

Friday night - wings. First burn on the egg. I (wisely, it turns out) bought the large adjustable rig with the extender and spider/ceramic stone combo from ceramicgrillstore.com. Without it, the large would be largely unusable for me. I cooked two large packs of wings and it took up both grates. I cooked indirect and in my ignorance of how the Egg burns (and the fact that the thermometer came completely uncalibrated) I got them way dry and crispy. Some were good, and my daughter's boyfriend and I ate them, but my wife and daughter were very anti-wing. 

Saturday - I went to my butcher Saturday morning and picked up 15lbs of beef ribs, two 8lb pork butts, and one 17lb packer brisket. I got my BBQ Guru CyberQ set up (I had performed the internal setup earlier in the week) and the fire rolling, then went in to open the ribs. Ugh, not what I ordered. They were about 2-3" long and cut crossways across the rib cage. NOT the dino bones I was hoping for. I need to explain to my butcher a little better what I'm looking for, because those things were a real disappointment. Some very hard fat and connective tissue that absolutely wouldn't render and they ended up dry. I was very disappointed in my ribs. Fail #2, but even more evidence that the adjustable rig is a complete necessity for me. I did learn throughout the cook how the Guru requires the vents to be set, and that was a good thing. I put my two butts on after dinner and let them cook overnight. I have to say, the Guru is absolutely incredible. I didn't fully trust it, so I woke up a few times to check it, and it was never 2* off of the set temp. I'm very happy with my decision to upgrade to the CyberQ since I can check it while I'm watching football and during the middle of the night. I came from a 250 gallon propane tank reverse flow stick burner that required me to wake up and fire it every 45-ish minutes. I can sleep and cook now!!!

Sunday - woke up to find that I was in the stall. No problems there - I was cooking around 225*. It took much longer than I expected to get through the stall. I ended up bumping the temp up until it was done around 5. The pork turned out very good - family said it was the best I've ever made. After dinner I did a quick complete clean of the egg for better airflow when cooking a brisket. I put the brisket on around 8 and went to bed.

Monday - took the brisket off around 3. Separated the point from the flat, wrapped the flat, and put it in the Yeti. I cubed the point and put it into a pan and threw it back in the egg for another 2.5 hours, then let it simmer in BBQ sauce for half an hour until it was all gooey and sticky. Right before I took it off the egg I sliced the flat and was pretty much devastated. The flat was incredibly dry - and I cooked to around 194*. The edges were like a brick, but the part from under the point was pretty good. I think I trimmed too much fat off during prep maybe? I don't know, but I need to work on my briskets. The burnt ends were cleaned up by the family and they raved over them (and demanded more!) 

My final thoughts: I wish I'd gone ahead and gotten the XL, but I think I'll end up with another large to complement the existing one. The Guru is the best investment I could have ever made. Charcoal usage is unbelieveable...I would call anyone who told me that it would use that little a liar had I not seen it with my own eyes. The adjustable rig is the second best investment that I could make. My table doesn't have enough work space - I'll have to use a portable table to hold all my "stuff." And I'm ready to sear a steak and cook a pizza now that I've burnt it in a little and not afraid to get the heat up.

Comments

  • I would get an XL to complement the large personally.  If you are cooking like you are... the extra space will be welcomed.  I have a 13" 18" and 24" KJ non BGE, however, the versatility in size is fantastic.  The xl will allow you to cook full racks of ribs, brisket without tinkering etc...

    I just ordered two new komodo Kamado cookers and went with a 23" and a 32"  Why have the same grill twice when you will have the same size restrictions is my thought.  The L and XL BGE will give you all the room that you need. 

    Smaller cooks on the large, larger cooks on the BGE, really big cooks or two temp required cooks use both!!


  • gdenby
    gdenby Posts: 6,239
    You certainly jumped in both feet first. I did cook 5 days out of seven for the first few weeks, but I didn't do a butt until after maybe 6 mos, and a brisket after 9. But I also didn't have an automated blower system.

    Some thoughts. Dome therm does need calibration, particularly after high temp sears.

     I usually don't do chicken indirect unless I'm roasting a whole stuffed bird.
    Small pieces like wings, single level, raised, turning 3, maybe 4 times till done. f more need doing than fit at once, I'm the last to eat.

    Beef ribs that are as long as you describe are usually chuck ribs. They tend to be tough without some braising in foil. Plate ribs are more like 6 -8" long, and are generally tender in about 4 hours indirect.

    No need too cook as low as 225F, which is somewhat difficult to do without an automated system. The main advantage to cooking in that range on the Egg is to give the meat as much time in the smoke as possible. "Turbo" cooks up around 325 - 350 turn out well, tho' I find the texture to be different, and the bark not as tasty.

    Briskets, well I've got a book I'm working on "Brisket FAILURE for complete idiots." I will tell you that my first error was cutting off too much fat. No fat cut off until the end, and then only if there is still too much. My hat is off to all those fine cooks in Texas and KC that make fine brisket. Myself, if I want to do a lot of beef, dino bones or tri-tip are easy-peasy.

    Good cooking to you. Pay attention, take notes if you like. There's lots of variables to stay on top of.
  • Welcome! You hit the ground running. Your cooks will get better and better on the egg. I can tell that you aren't scared of screwing up and that is a good thing. 

    I started off with a large, I then added a second large. So far two larges is perfect for me. 

    I also needed more table space so I had two tables built earlier this year. Egging was fun before, but now it is even more enjoyable. 


    Louisville, GA - 2 Large BGE's
  • I was able to fit everything that I cooked in the L, it was just really tight. Definitely no room for sides, which disappoints me a bit. For fear of having to hire a divorce attorney I'll stick with squeezing things on the L for now, maybe another one next spring? 

    I jumped in feet first because while I'm new to the Egg, I'm not new to low and slow cooking. Honestly, I did 225 because the blower allowed me to :) I've done butts around 300 and there's not that much difference. Butts are easy though - and very forgiving. Brisket - not so much. I don't need the book mentioned because I've managed to fail in quite the spectacular fashion all by myself! 

    I'm definitely not scared...it's just meat. I've always been of the mindset that cooking like we do is part art, part science. While many hold fast to their workflows for cooking, I really enjoy experimenting - every now and then I screw up and manage to make something better!
  • theyolksonyou
    theyolksonyou Posts: 18,459
    edited September 2015
    Jickey said:
    For fear of having to hire a divorce attorney I'll stick with squeezing things on the L for now, maybe another one next spring? 




    Take take her to an eggfest and introduce yourself to the cooks and she can see many people with 5 or more eggs. 

    Made my second one look tame.  =)