Smokeware cap or no Smokeware cap...I can't decide

chrisc133 · May 2015

My kamado was FINALLY delivered on Monday after weeks of waiting. I can't decide if I want to add the Smokeware cap or not. It seems most have good experiences--but a few reviews mentioned it's not easy to maintain low and slow temps due to more air getting in from the top. I've played around with the daisy wheel and I seem to have no problems opening and closing and maintaining the daisy wheel position. I'm most interested in the Smokeware cap for being able to BBQ in the rain through the pop-up showers in the South. Any thoughts?

By the way, first cook pics will be coming soon. I thawed a rack of baby backs and I have 4 bone-in chicken breasts I plan to use to make some jerk chicken. It should be a good weekend.

RRP · May 2015

Using the gasket that came with my SmokeWare made a tight fit for me. I prefer to place the gasket inside on the cap itself and not on the neck of the dome. Since I bought my cap nearly 3 years ago I have never even once gone back to the daisy.

aukerns08 · May 2015

I have the Smokeware Cap on my Large and I have no issues going low and slow or controlling temps. I have no complaints and I like it. I've really only needed it maybe once or twice for overnight cooks when rain popped up so I'm not sure I need it but it's on there now and works great.

Fred19Flintstone · May 2015

When you get right down to the nitty gritty, it's personal preference. You're taking a $40 gamble. I like mine. You have to use it a bit to "learn it". It doesn't take long.

Jeepster47 · May 2015

Since one can snuff out the fire with a Smokeware cap, there should be no problems maintaining low-n-slow temps with the cap.

chrisc133 · May 2015

Jeepster47 said:

Since one can snuff out the fire with a Smokeware cap, there should be no problems maintaining low-n-slow temps with the cap.

no issues snuffing out the fire? Some of the negative reviews mentioned increased lump usage due to not being able to quickly snuff out the fire.

theyolksonyou · May 2015

No issues. Ran 210 grid all night last Saturday. Snuffs out no problem. Especially after it builds up a little gunk.

Legume · May 2015

Like mine, all of the reasons above. I was daisy wheel challenged.

Jeepster47 · May 2015

@chrisc133 ... the Smokeware cap, like the Daisy Wheel, has moving parts to provide variable size openings. The moving parts have to have clearances or they would freeze up with the grease and other gunk that passes through. When both units are closed there is some air leakage due to those clearances. How much leakage depends on the tolerance stack-up in your particular unit. BGE provides a ceramic cap to alleviate any leakage. Smokeware is coming out with a lid to provide the same positive sealing as the ceramic cap.

bo31210 · May 2015

My daisy wheel and ceramic top are still sealed int eh original box after I transferred the Smokeware cap from my MBGE to the LBGE. Never looked back on it Love mine

DoofusOfTheDay · May 2015

Love mine, especially like not having to worry if it's raining out.

carwash66 · May 2015

Hi guys. Been lurking on the forum a long time. For the past 25 years have used the ceramic lids. Bought the daisy wheels for both eggs (lg & med). Tried, but like the original lid better. Maybe just old habits. Will give the Smokeware a look Sat. at Eggfest. Thanks for all the great info here.

SoCalTim · May 2015

The Smokeware Cap sure is pretty ... other than that, the BGE Daisy Wheel has given me no problems. I'll keep using it.

pescadorzih · May 2015

I love my smokeware , no problem maintaining low temps. I still use the ceramic cap to snuff the fire.

Jeepster47 · May 2015

bo31210 said:

My daisy wheel and ceramic top are still sealed int eh original box after I transferred the Smokeware cap from my MBGE to the LBGE. Never looked back on it Love mine

My dealer switched out the Daisy Wheel for a Smokeware cap when I bought my second egg. That saved me some money and it was a deal for him also. Then my son made the same deal on his second egg. Turns out that the Daisy Wheel breaks if dropped (dah) ... he sells a number of them through out the year.

dblalock1030 · May 2015

Jeepster47 said:

@chrisc133 ... the Smokeware cap, like the Daisy Wheel, has moving parts to provide variable size openings. The moving parts have to have clearances or they would freeze up with the grease and other gunk that passes through. When both units are closed there is some air leakage due to those clearances. How much leakage depends on the tolerance stack-up in your particular unit. BGE provides a ceramic cap to alleviate any leakage. Smokeware is coming out with a lid to provide the same positive sealing as the ceramic cap.

Any more information on this positive sealing Smokeware cap that is similar to the ceramic cap?

Jeepster47 · May 2015

@dblalock1030 ... just to be clear, the function is similar to the ceramic cap, not the form. In use, you'd lift up the top half, drop the lid into the bottom half of the cap, and then replace the top half.

Here's a thread showing what the prototype looks like: http://eggheadforum.com/discussion/1180306/put-a-lid-on-it-ii#P1

fence0407 · May 2015

Get one. Wish they made one for the mini...

Jeepster47 · May 2015

@fence0407 ... when Matt sent me the prototype lid, he mentioned that he has an adapter being tested by someone right now. The cost of tooling to manufacture the cap is prohibitive, so no custom sized cap for the MM and the small. Don't know timing or anything like that, but I'd guess before the end of the year.

Matt is supposed to attend the North GA Mountain Eggfest this weekend ... go bug him to hurry up.

chrisc133 · May 2015

aukerns08 said:

I have the Smokeware Cap on my Large and I have no issues going low and slow or controlling temps. I have no complaints and I like it. I've really only needed it maybe once or twice for overnight cooks when rain popped up so I'm not sure I need it but it's on there now and works great.

I probably will pick one up--it's really not that expensive of an investment.

I'll be doing my cooks on the back deck--but when it rains, do you see any problems with rolling it onto the screened in porch for a low and slow?

WeberWho · May 2015

No need for a top unless you're doing low and slows. You can control the temp from the bottom vent for anything 275+. The only time I use the daisy wheel is for low and slow cooks and for smoke flavor. Otherwise I find the top pointless

Jeepster47 · May 2015

@chrisc133 ... why move it out of the rain? That it's rainproof is one of the neat features of the cap.

fence0407 · May 2015

Jeepster47 said:

@fence0407 ... when Matt sent me the prototype lid, he mentioned that he has an adapter being tested by someone right now. The cost of tooling to manufacture the cap is prohibitive, so no custom sized cap for the MM and the small. Don't know timing or anything like that, but I'd guess before the end of the year.

Matt is supposed to attend the North GA Mountain Eggfest this weekend ... go bug him to hurry up.

Nice! I bugged him a little at last year's fest, but won't be there this year. In all reality, the mini doesn't really need a cap of any sort. As @Mickey can attest to, most temp control can be done by using the bottom vent only. I would however buy one for the mini bc it'd look cool next to my large egg.

chrisc133 · May 2015

Jeepster47 said:

@chrisc133 ... why move it out of the rain? That it's rainproof is one of the neat features of the cap.

With the daisy wheel I mean...until the cap comes in.

Ozzie_Isaac · May 2015

I didn't even get the daisy wheel from my dealer for my medium. just got the smokeware. Have it on both my eggs.

RRP · May 2015

do you see any problems with rolling it onto the screened in porch for a low and slow?

I know people do it, but why take the risk of something catching on fire - as it has happened! Besides you're not made of sugar are you? Then you won't melt in the rain!

Ladeback69 · May 2015

Jeepster47 said:

bo31210 said:

My daisy wheel and ceramic top are still sealed int eh original box after I transferred the Smokeware cap from my MBGE to the LBGE. Never looked back on it Love mine

My dealer switched out the Daisy Wheel for a Smokeware cap when I bought my second egg. That saved me some money and it was a deal for him also. Then my son made the same deal on his second egg. Turns out that the Daisy Wheel breaks if dropped (dah) ... he sells a number of them through out the year.

Interesting, my dealer said that their distributor limits what non BGE stuff for the Egg they can sell. I told them about it, but they said BGE and their distributor wouldn't allow them too. I think this may be on my list for my birthday this summer.

RRP · May 2015

Ladeback69 said:

Interesting, my dealer said that their distributor limits what non BGE stuff for the Egg they can sell. I told them about it, but they said BGE and their distributor wouldn't allow them too.

Me thinks your dealer has a control clown as a distributor! If it was MY store I would sell what I wanted to!

jaydub58 · May 2015

I have not used either Daisy Wheel or Ceramic Cap since I got my Smokeware last year.

EggHead_Bubba · May 2015

RRP said:

Ladeback69 said:

Interesting, my dealer said that their distributor limits what non BGE stuff for the Egg they can sell. I told them about it, but they said BGE and their distributor wouldn't allow them too.

Me thinks your dealer has a control clown as a distributor! If it was MY store I would sell what I wanted to!

Unless of course if BGE told the dealer of the arrangement and would pull their dealership if violated.

Mickey · May 2015

carwash66 said:

Hi guys. Been lurking on the forum a long time. For the past 25 years have used the ceramic lids. Bought the daisy wheels for both eggs (lg & med). Tried, but like the original lid better. Maybe just old habits. Will give the Smokeware a look Sat. at Eggfest. Thanks for all the great info here.

Please call me 254.630.8399
mickey

Smokeware cap or no Smokeware cap...I can't decide

Comments

Categories