Best PULLED PORK I've had.... and FIRST TIME egging it!

KiterTodd

Was planning on smoking a small pork butt Sunday morning, but thanks to a search on this forum I realized it was likely I’d miss dinner on a low and slow.  So, my 6 lbs shoulder went on at 1:30AM for an overnight.   Had the remote thermometer next to me to keep tabs on things from bed.   My goal was 250 and it did a very slow climb over the night from 230 up to 280.  I closed the grates a hair more at 7:AM and then it settled around 250 for the rest of the cook.

Before cooking I rubbed the meat with brown sugar and olive oil, then a layer of yellow mustard and finally dry rubbed it with Dizzy Dust and Bad Byrons (didn’t have enough Dizzy to go around).  I used RO lump and put in several Jack Daniels whiskey barrel wood chunks.



I did not even crack that grill until the meat hit 200 degrees.  I love that about the Egg!  If you keep the temps right, you just let it do it’s thing and enjoy the transformation reveal at the end of the cook.  The meat hit temp after 11 hours.  It looked like a proper meteorite!   

I stuck a meat thermometer in several places (it went in and out soooo easily, so I knew it was DONE) and it read between 200 and 206 everywhere.   Awesome!   I wrapped it in foil with a little apple juice and cider vinegar which I shook in the empty Dizzy Dust container for good measure.  FTC for an hour (the family was hungry…I promised them pulled pork for lunch).



I have smoked butts before (used to do it indirect on a gas, low and slow with smoker box, texas crutch after 4 hours) and this was HANDS DOWN THE BEST PULLED PORK I’VE EVER MADE and AS GOOD as any pulled pork I have ever tried!!!!  It was incredible.  I am a bit of a pulled pork snob.  I like it Carolina style with a little coleslaw on top.  The meat should have smokey flavor and be tender and moist.  I laid this up on a soft white bun and the meat was sooooo tender you bit right into the bun and cleanly through all the meat.  It was awesome!  

As you experienced eggers know, pulling this was a non event.  It just fell apart in moist juicy lumps as soon as I hit it with a fork….iiiiiiit waaaaaaas  aaaaawwwweeeesooooooome!   I put it in a bowl, tossed it with a little fresh made NC vinegar BBQ sauce and it was ready to go.





So what is the best way to reheat pork after you pull it and recreate the fresh pulled experience?  It was great fresh.  I reheated some gently this week…it was still very good but not that orgasmic juicy tenderness of when I just pulled it.  I'd like to make a few butts ahead of time for a party.



As always, this forum is a great resource and made my first pork shoulder simple and fun!

HDumptyEsq

That looks like a brilliant cook.

Avoid dry heat for reheating and don't nuke it. Put some in a plastic bag and put in very hot water till heated thru.

gdenby

Everything went right. I spent months fussing over exact temps, but finally realized that a slow rise like you had, followed by a tweak would set the temperature well enough, and that i should stop fussing.

Part of the fresh pulled experience is the aroma. Don't know if that can be retained. If the meat gets warm enough to let warm water vapor carry the smell, it will also become drier.

I've been messing with making "pork jelly" by pressure cooking neck bones in a small amount of water. Adding that into the pulled mass helps a little, but still not quite right.

johnmitchell

Now that's what I'am talking about...Flippen Awesome..Congratulations all round..That sandwich would stand no chance with me..Good one.. :-c

KiterTodd

gdenby said:

I've been messing with making "pork jelly" by pressure cooking neck bones in a small amount of water. Adding that into the pulled mass helps a little, but still not quite right.

There was a nice juice in the foil after I let it FTC.  I suppose I could retain that when I'm reheating in bulk. 
Thanks!

GQuiz

Beautiful. Now I'm starving. Long time until lunch.

tulocay

Great looking butt.

DMW

=D> =D> =D>

Cowdogs

Sometimes 10 hours of anticipation creates a taste that is hard to replicate with a microwave.

caliking

I need one of those sammiches.

BTW, I drink the juice left in the foil. It's concentrated pork but porkiness.

tksmoke

That looks GREAT!!!  Nice cook!

otter

Nice Job (:

cook861

that looks  soo good im going to be doing a pork but  today hope mine turns half as good as yours 

fence0407

My stomach is growling looking at those pictures! Nice job!

KiterTodd

Thanks for the enthusiasm and support!

Don't think I don't notice my wife rolling her eyes as I'm taking pictures of my food....  
)

itsmce

Nice...

cajuncook

And that is the reason I no longer go to BBQ restaurants. I've never found one that comes close to what I can make on my eggs.

thailandjohn

A good pork butt is the best......looks great

fence0407

KiterTodd said:

Thanks for the enthusiasm and support!

Don't think I don't notice my wife rolling her eyes as I'm taking pictures of my food....  
)

My wife always rolls her eyes at me when I take pictures of my cooks!

Grillmagic

Don't be getting a big head now your next cook may only be 99% as good!

That looks yummy....

Chuck King

Dimondale, Michigan

www.chuckkingcomedy.com

tksmoke

Grillmagic said:

Don't be getting a big head now your next cook may only be 99% as good!

That looks yummy....

Chuck King

Dimondale, Michigan

www.chuckkingcomedy.com

But it may also be 100% better!!!

ericp

WOW!!!! That color on the bark is amazing. looks awesome

anzyegg

Excellent cook!!!

ivada

That looks awesome indeed!!!  My first butt on the Egg was as satisfying as yours seemed to be.  Love the Egg!  Can almost taste that sammy...

boochsr71

looks awesome!

Hibby

That right there Sir, was an excellent write-up. Pictures are awesome - especially the 'reveal'. Keep up the good work.

drewmack

L

drewmack

Did you go fat cap up?

KiterTodd

drewmack said:

Did you go fat cap up?

Yes, fat cap up.  The white part you see is where the bark cracked as the fat reduced (I guess).
What do you do?

I've seen both sides discussed.  I seem to always put the fat cap on top to let it baste the meat as it melts.  Seem to work fine and I'll continue to do that. 
The only negative I can see is that if you really like bark, you typically lose the bark on the fat cap (unless you eat all the fat) and the bark on the bottom doesn't build up as thick since you are sitting on the grill grates.  I seemed to have plenty left for my taste, though.

HDumptyEsq

KiterTodd said:

drewmack said:

Did you go fat cap up?

Yes, fat cap up.  The white part you see is where the bark cracked as the fat reduced (I guess).
What do you do?

I've seen both sides discussed.  I seem to always put the fat cap on top to let it baste the meat as it melts.  Seem to work fine and I'll continue to do that. 
The only negative I can see is that if you really like bark, you typically lose the bark on the fat cap (unless you eat all the fat) and the bark on the bottom doesn't build up as thick since you are sitting on the grill grates.  I seemed to have plenty left for my taste, though.

Don't f#%k with perfection.

smokesniffer

:-c Nice Job. The egg does a perfect job of low and slow pork.