Welcome to the EGGhead Forum - a great place to visit and packed with tips and EGGspert advice! You can also join the conversation and get more information and amazing kamado recipes by following Big Green Egg at:
Cowboy was my only choice for a while in my area. I didn't like seeing wood flooring cutoffs in the early years (about 4 years ago), but it still burned well, although a little sparky. My Wallyworld started carrying RO, and had it on sale for $5/8.8# bag last year, so I bought a bunch. Saw that Lowes had Cowboy in 20# bags for $9.99, so I bought a few of those bags. It's been fine, lights as easy as RO for me, and now that it's not a bag of hardwood floor cutoffs, it has similar makeup of larges and dust as the RO. I use veg oil and a paper towel with all my lump. I'm thinking you may have gotten a bad bag? On another note, the worst lump I've gotten has been an off brand that was mesquite lump. I thought it was good in the beginning, but talk about a strong smoke flavor. It took over everything I cooked on it.