Big Green Egg - EGGhead Forum - The Ultimate Cooking Experience...
Welcome to the EGGhead Forum - a great place to visit and packed with tips and EGGspert advice! You can also join the conversation and get more information and amazing kamado recipes by following Big Green Egg at:

Facebook  |  Twitter  |  Instagram  |  Pinterest  |  Youtube  |  Vimeo
Share your photos by tagging us and using the hashtag #EGGhead4Life.

In Atlanta? Come visit Big Green Egg headquarters, including our retail showroom, the History of the EGG Museum and Culinary Center!  3786 DeKalb Technology Parkway, Atlanta, GA 30340.

1st Boston Butt on the BGE

TheLazyCTheLazyC Posts: 97
edited 11:35PM in EggHead Forum
I put two 8lb butts on at 250 and they were to temp in only 9 hours, which came in about 3 hours early based on the 1.5 hours per pound that I was expecting.

I was somewhat disapointed, when I pulled them off they were 187-212 degrees according to the ThermoPen, I was hoping they would be falling apart but only sections.

Had a good flavor, is there anything I could have done to get them falling to peices?

And also, I calibrting my thermometer AFTER the cook and it came in 12 degrees off, at boiling point it was reading 200 so I adjusted to 212 which means my butt cooked at approx 238 dome.


  • skihornskihorn Posts: 600
    I have only done three butts, so I am no expert. Mine have all taken MUCH longer and I was doing them at roughly the same temp as you.

    The one comment I can offer is you say the thermopen had it at 187 to 212. Normally I would just use the lowest temp I can find in the meat (usually at the center). Therefore, my thinking is that means you pulled it at 187. That is about 10 degrees cooler than when I have pulled mine. That would partly explain the time difference, but I still wouldn't have expected that big a difference. That may also explain the tenderness. I have pulled all three of mine in the 197 range, wrapped and rested in a cooler and found it to be VERY tender and falling apart.

    League City, TX
  • TheLazyCTheLazyC Posts: 97
    I guess I am just going to have to cook another and another until I get it right! :)
  • skihornskihorn Posts: 600
    That's the spirit!

    Big pieces of meat are intimidating, because it usually means you have a lot of guests over and want it to be just right. I don't ever cook a brisket or butt just for the immediate family, so it is hard to experiment. For my first butt I did it for my inlaws. Perfect combo as there were eight of us eating (enough to justify a butt) but being my inlaws I didn't really care if it wasn't good. :)

    League City, TX
  • srq2625srq2625 Posts: 262
    It's just the DW and me at home now and I cook a couple of pork butts every once in a while (they come in twos from CostCo).

    I find that if you FoodSaver them in smaller amounts and then freeze them they defrost and warm very nicely.

    So, no need to wait for a crowd - practice and enjoy the dividends!
  • probe1957probe1957 Posts: 222
    I am with Skihorn. Your butt just wasn't done. Fortunately there is a long weekend coming up so you can cook another. :)
  • Capt. RichCapt. Rich Posts: 153
    Did my first Boston Butt this past Sunday. It really was awesome. 5.7 lbs seasoned it with some yellow mustard & bone suckin mustard, then rubbed on a coat of Bad Byrons Butt Rub. Cooked it about 10 1/2 hours. It literally just fell apart.
Sign In or Register to comment.
Click here for Forum Use Guidelines.