Standing rib road question

BobbyG · December 2002

Is there a difference between a standing rib roast and a prime rib? Ok I know the rib road has bones, but is it really the same cut of meat?[p]Any other info you have is very welcome.[p]Thanks, BobbyG

Unknown · December 2002

BobbyG,
The main difference seems to be the availablity. Butchers often don't sell "bone in" until the holidays, whereas you can get a boneless pretty much anytime, provided you have a decent butcher or meat supplier.[p]As for cooking, I'm gonna guess and say the bone in roast will take a bit longer. [p]Check out Tim M's web site.[p]http://www.tm52.com/bge/[p]He is the font of much BGE knowledge in these parts.[p]Good luck![p]

Bordello · December 2002

BobbyG,
Prime is the highest grade, next is choice, the roast are the same but the grading is what makes the difference. Prime can sometimes be hard to find, it is what the high end restaurant's use. Get prime if you can.
New Bob

Rumrunner · December 2002

BobbyG,
In answer to your question, YES and NO, it is the same piece of meat. Let me explain...years ago, and now in some northern states at smaller grocers or meat markets, when you ordered a 'prime' rib, that meant you wanted the first three or four ribs (considered the prime of the rib) and the rest of the rib was sold as a 'standing rib' roast. These were normally cut from USDA Choice Beef and there was a 50 cent per pound difference between the two cuts.
USDA Prime Beef was hard to get because mostly your finer hotels and restaurants were the ones to receive this grade of meat. In the past few years the USDA has restructured their grading, due to better grown cattle, etc, and PRIME grade beef is more plentiful and easier to obtain.
The cost difference between a high grade of CHOICE and PRIME is substantial, but the taste difference is minimal. I always go with the CHOICE. Not with any "CHOICE" because they vary in quality. Again, let me explain, when grading beef (there are many, many criterium) you may have a steer that is not NOT quite Select Grade (poor), so it will be graded as CHOICE (better). Another side of beef may NOT quite meet PRIME quality (but is darn close) and will be graded as Choice. These different quailities of CHOICE will be bid on and bought by various beef packers. IBP, Iowa Beef Packers, buys the top quality choice beef. Am I making any sense here?
Anyway, ask your butcher to cut you a standing rib roast from IBP and you can't go wrong. I prefer ribs 4, 5 and 6 because of the fat content. 1, 2 and 3 will be leaner, but still tasty. Any more questions just remove the NO from my email address. Btw, I've been cutting meat since 1965.
Rum

BobbyG · December 2002

Rumrunner,
Wow!! Thanks for the information. I could certianly tell you knew what you were talking about and I was wondering as I was reading how you gained your knowledge, of course you answered that question in the end. One of the great things aobut the BGE site is people like yourself willing to share the "secrets" and "tricks". It takes a long time to learn the tricks and I really appreciate you sharing. [p]I think I'll go with your suggestion of the 3,4,5 ribs and I'll do this for our xmas dinner with special friends.
Thanks, BobbyG

Bordello · December 2002

Rumrunner,
Thanks for an in-depth understanding of the prime rib, always nice to learn from the members of the BGE forum.
Cheers,
New Bob

Hammer · December 2002

Rumrunner,
Thanks for the information! This was very useful.
Thanks
Hammer

Standing rib road question

Comments

Categories