First time ordering name brand commercial rubs, what should I get first? Any must tries?

DinnerIsComing · July 2015

So I'm about to order some commercial rubs for the first time. Usually use stuff found in the grocery store or the hardware stores grill section. For my last 2 pork butt smokes, I used this stuff.

http://www.thekansascitybbqstore.com/products/cowtown-the-squeal-hog-rub

My local Ace sells it. Good rub, but at $6 + tax for a 6.5oz jar, its pretty pricey.

The big 2 commercial rub providers I keep seeing pop up is Dizzy Pig and Meat Church. I can only get a variety pack of rubs from one or the other at this time.

Which do you recommend? Of their entire offerings, which are must haves? Any other commercial rub recommendations?

It would probably help to list what I plan to cook. In the next month, my low and slow BBQs will be smoking a chuck roast for pulled beef, maybe a pork butt somewhere, and definitely some ribs. Standard day to day cooks will include, chicken breasts, pork chops, spatchcock chickens, burgers and dogs/sausages. I usually cook veggies/sides on the grill as well, so any you recommend for the side stuff will be considered as well.

Thanks!

DaveRichardson · July 2015

Meat Church is great!

txhawkeye · July 2015

You can't go wrong with Butt Rub

MrCookingNurse · July 2015

Some of my favorites. I have a huge selection but could do it all with these and basic seasonings.

Image: https://us.v-cdn.net/5017260/uploads/editor/6t/hwah9v8twdpx.jpg

I really think the dizzy pig's are over priced and over rated....... (drop the mic..... walk away)......

DinnerIsComing · July 2015

@MrCookingNurse Appreciate the honesty about Dizzy Pig! You're the first naysayer I've seen but I will say I've seen Meat Church pop more in peoples blogs/recipes than Dizzy Pig.

I like Meat Church's pricing better, I know that.

Jeepster47 · July 2015

Don't forget to look at Oakridge BBQ rubs ... they have two sample packs that will give you a good overview. Their Dominator Sweet Rib Rub is excellent on pork ribs. And, their Habanero Death Dust will light your fire ... literally.

Sample packs from each of the companies is not a bad way to go. Cook two rib racks with different sample rubs on each one and you can get a quick read on what the family likes. With a sample pack approach that's about a $2 experiment instead of $20 with normal size bottles.

Hi54putty · July 2015

I'm a huge Joh Henry fan. They have about 50 rubs and all are great. The hot sugar maple is one of my favorites on butts.

stlcharcoal · July 2015

I usually make my own rubs, but Dizzy Pig's selection for seasonings is really high quality stuff. I use a lot of their Raging River on fish; and Cow Lick on beef. Their Fajita'ish and Mediterranean'ish are really good as is Shakin the Tree and Pineapple.

Everything I've tried for rubs is always WAY too salty. So I make my own.

MrCookingNurse · July 2015

Oh, I almost forgot John Henry. Great stuff. I think it's regional but a great one is the Alabama Butt Rub. Dizzy pig is a quality product, I think I have one of each but hardly use them and have found cheaper/better things.

Gonnaneedabiggeregg · July 2015

Dizzy Pig Swamp Venom. It's the go to rub for great wings. Blues Hog is great on butts.

BuckeyeBob · July 2015

I usually make my own also but do like the DizzyPig rubs. While they still have a lot of salt, they aren't nearly as salty as a lot of the other ones out there. I have heard a lot of good things about MeatChurch but haven't tried it yet.

Thatgrimguy · July 2015

Money rub from Big poppa smoker is my favorite chicken and rib rub. Bad Byrons butt rub is my go to butt rub. And I still like having a ton of options for variety.

But if I had to buy just one commercial rub it would be MONEY

PlanoPokes79 · July 2015

John Henry pecan and add garlic or black pepper. ...nuff said.

henapple · July 2015

Head Country rub and sauce.

gdenby · July 2015

I've heard a lot of good stuff about Meat Church over the past few months, but have not had a chance to try them. I notice they don't offer sampler packs.

I've been using DP rubs for years now, and wouldn't be without several of them. DP does offer sampler packs. Also, Egger Smokin' Guitar Player at Tasty Licks BBQ offers his own samplers, as well as DPs. Those might be a good way to get an idea of how different blends work w. different foods.

John Henry's is good too, but there were a couple that I wasn't thrilled by. There was an all pupose herbal blend that I used right up on just about everything.

Penzey's has a good selection, and another branch of the family runs a place called the Spice House. I like their "Bronzeville Rib Rub" a lot.

I hate to say this, but $6 bucks for 6.5 oz is a steal if its not mostly sugar and salt. I've paid up to $7/oz for some premium stuff, and there are brands that run 10/oz.

I've been messing w. making my own rubs for awhile. Only decent, but the base is really inexpensive. Sugar, salt, black and cayenne pepper, onion and garlic powder. There are several asian and oriental markets in my area. They sell whole spices very cheaply, and the whole spices have a long shelf life. (I've read nutmeg unground remains good for 100 years.) So I take my base, and grind or mince up some stuff right before using, and add as I like.

DinnerIsComing · July 2015

$6/6.5oz may sound like a steal, but it's really not. Also, the #1 ingredient on the rub is salt. I was just pricing the Meat Church 3 lb value pack. 3 1 lb. bags of different rubs for $36.95 delivered to my door. That breaks down to about .78/oz vs the about $1 or more an ounce for store bought stuff. They even say to contact them for 5 lb bulk discounts. So there is even deeper discounting available.

I like John Henry, being a big fan of the "Chicken Tickler" rub in his line but my wife doesn't care for it. She used to be ok with it but after a few cooks with it, she grew a strong dislike for it and now she's written off John Henry all together. Very disappointing as I was very fond of the Chicken Tickler.

biggreenrob · July 2015

For the standard day to day cooks that you mentioned, you can't go wrong with Dizzy Pig. Try their Dizzy Dust. My personal favorite is Raging River. I prefer to make my own but you can't go wrong with any of the suggestions others have recommended. Good luck.

DinnerIsComing · July 2015

I think I'm going to buy the Dizzy Pig sampler and Oak Ridge sampler to start. Good price to "try" out a lot of different varieties. If Meat Church had a sampler, I would get one from them as well.

Thanks all for the recommendations. I'll try Meat Church another time.

BOWHUNR · July 2015

You can't go wrong with the Dizzy Pig line. I have and use them all except for the Bombay Curry-ish and that's only because I'm not a fan of curry. As said above I like rubs that aren't too salty and Dizzy Pig is a perfect fit.

Mike

BYS1981 · July 2015

I primarily make my own rubs.. I use a dr bbq recipe, but I have bought dizzy pig and I liked them.

Legume · July 2015

Plowboys Yardbird is a great staple to have in your cabinet. Great go-to rub for anything.

paqman · July 2015

For chicken: Plowboys Yardbird, Dizzy Pig Raging River, Dizzy Pig Jamaican Firewalk, Bone Suckin Rub.

For pork: Dizzy Pig Dizzy Dust, Dizzy Pig Raging River

For beef: Schwartz's Beef Seasoning (you have to order from Canada)

Dizzy Pig Raging River is my favorite rub; it is good on everything (cheese, as a rimmer on bloody Ceasars/Mary, etc). Dizzy Dust and Jamaican Firewalk are also excellent. I have tried most of their other rubs and while they are good, I don't care too much for them.

MrCookingNurse · July 2015

Head country Hot bbq is awrsome

biggreenrob · July 2015

Any interest in making your own rubs?

DinnerIsComing · July 2015

I haven't ordered any samplers yet. Still on the fence.

Yes @biggreenrob, I am interested in making my own rubs but I do know that it can get quite expensive, depending on what you're making.

Also, a lot of people have the attitude of why attempt to reinvent the wheel when so many others have already done the experimenting and perfecting.

SGH · July 2015

MrCookingNurse said:

Some of my favorites.

I couldn't help but to notice the Tony Chacheres above. I go through quite a bit of it myself on fresh seafood and fish. It is excellent on most saltwater fish.

chrisc133 · July 2015

Where are you located? Kroger sells Bad Byrons Butt Rub in store down here. I have a bottle of it, Dizzy Pig, and the Costco Rib Rub.

DinnerIsComing · July 2015

Southwest Florida. Butt Rub is available in stores here. It's ok but not my favorite. Only found one store located on the Dizzy Pig locator near me but based on their site, I question if they sell retail products anymore.

gdenby · July 2015

DinnerIsComing said:

I haven't ordered any samplers yet. Still on the fence.

...

Also, a lot of people have the attitude of why attempt to reinvent the wheel when so many others have already done the experimenting and perfecting.

There are lots of wheels. Its all a matter of taste, yours and your guests. And the basics are really simple. Salt and smoke. Probably some pepper and something sweet.

For me, I started working on my own rubs when I ran out of commercial, and had to improvise quickly. Panic! Thankfully, my then limited spice cabinet had enough different things to try and fake it. Nothing in there was exotic, except some cloves, and nothing was expensive.

Then there is the matter of combining flavors in the whole meal. A little nutmeg or some lemon grass powder in a few things can tie different portions together.

MrCookingNurse · July 2015

@SGH Tony's is on our table every meal. Fries, spaghetti, everything.....

I really like the blue one on chicken

HofstraJet · July 2015

DinnerIsComing said:

Southwest Florida. Butt Rub is available in stores here. It's ok but not my favorite. Only found one store located on the Dizzy Pig locator near me but based on their site, I question if they sell retail products anymore.

If you come to the east side of Alligator Alley, there's a shop in Coral Springs right off of the Sawgrass Expressway that has the full Dizzy Pig line (Grill N Propane). I bought my egg and many eggcessories there. Just ask for Roy.

First time ordering name brand commercial rubs, what should I get first? Any must tries?

Comments

Categories