Big Green Egg - EGGhead Forum - The Ultimate Cooking Experience...
We’re so close to Thanksgiving that we can taste it and we’re ready to help you prepare the most delicious Thanksgiving feast you’ve ever cooked! Check out our Turkey Cheat Sheet for turkey tips, our Thanksgiving page for turkey recipes, and our Holiday Entertaining Publication for all other Thanksgiving needs to help you make this the best Thanksgiving yet! PS. Don’t forget about breakfast Thanksgiving morning either!

Big Green Egg headquarters has moved - come visit our new showroom and check out the museum and culinary center too! 3786 DeKalb Technology Parkway, Atlanta, GA 30340.

New BGE owner + this forum= Awesome first Pork butt

YankeeQYankeeQ Posts: 12
Hi all,

I'm officially a part of the BGE family after years of dreaming. Since the first day of ownership of my LBGE, I've been practically living on this forum, soaking up all the tips, tricks and useful information shared by others, to make my first smoke as simple and problem free as possible.

Monday (Memorial day):
Picked up LBGE, plate setter, BGE lump & apple wood chunks

After a few days of reading the forum, I finally built up enough confidence to fire up "Big Berta" (nickname for my Egg) so I headed out to my local butcher to pickup a 8LB boneless shoulder (it was the only shoulder he had) and a bottle of "Memphis Belle BBQ rub" from Chef Central.
The shoulder was washed, dried and lathered up with yellow mustard, followed by a healthy dusting of rub mixed with 1/2 cup of Turbinado sugar.

Friday night:
11pm- Stacked lump in Egg according to tips found on this forum, added a drip pan with a little water and fired her up! It took me 2hrs to figure out how to stabilize the temp to around 250* dome.

1am- Once everything looked good and stable, I added the meat - BUT, that's where things went downhill (literally). The temp started to drop, but I figured it was normal due to the meat being a little colder than room temperature, so I didn't panic (not yet at least).

3am- After a quick sleep, I woke up to check on the Egg, only to find the dome gauge at ZERO! I quickly checked the meat internal temp on the Maverick and it said 95*. Now I'm in full panic mode, with every PC & iPad in the house logged into the forum trying to figure out if the meat is salvageable. Heck I don't wanna kill my family on my first smoke (My mother-in-law on the other hand.....) with contaminated meat.

3:15am- I re-lit Berta and got her up to temp within minutes. By this time I weighed out my options and decided to throw the meat back on (again, after reading advice given to others on the forum).

9am: Temp is rock solid at 250 dome
12pm: Egg is on the back deck under the full blast of the sun and 90* NYC weather, but temp is still steady at 250-255
4pm: Maverick screamed out at 195* internal temp, so I opened up Big Berta to inspect my creation.. I swore it was like the heavens opened up and the angels were sitting on my shoulders singing Starship's "we built this city (on pork and beef) ". It took serious self control not to tear into it like Tiny Tim on a Thanksgiving Turkey, but I know the experts called for it to be wrapped in foil and towels for at least 4hrs, so that's exactly what I did.

All in all, I was pretty happy with the outcome. No one got sick, the flavor was passable for my first time, the meat was moist and I didn't burn the house down. On my next smoke, I'll be use some Dizzy Dust with a little added sugar and hickory chunks together with the apple to give it some more smoke flavor.

Thank you to everyone on this forum for your help. Your advice helped me to successfully smoke my first Butt!


Pizza I made yesterday was also amazing!
Westchester, NY
LBGE + Guru controller

BBQ & Horsepower = My Life!


  • hapsterhapster Posts: 7,267
    And pictures on his first post...

    Off to a good looking start. Enjoy... Now start cooking and get that thing dirty, it looks like one of the fancy models from the BGE Cookbook ;)
  • Little StevenLittle Steven Posts: 27,577
    Really eh? Nice cook and pics! Did you do the PP just for the pie or make sammies?


    Caledon, ON


  • YankeeQYankeeQ Posts: 12
    Thanks guys! As you can tell, I'm in love with my BGE :-D (my wife is jealous lol)

    Little Steven, the Pizza had cured ham my sister boiled & grilled before putting it on the pie.

    On Father's day weekend we're doing a 15lb packer Brisket. I can't wait!
    Westchester, NY
    LBGE + Guru controller

    BBQ & Horsepower = My Life!
  • YankeeQYankeeQ Posts: 12
    The pizza stone was a Kitchen Aid brand we've been using for years.. I took an angle grinder to the corners, so how it fits the Egg like a glove. No sense in buying a 16" round stone :-D
    Westchester, NY
    LBGE + Guru controller

    BBQ & Horsepower = My Life!
  • CharlieTNCharlieTN Posts: 177
    Welcome aboard.  I got almost no sleep during my first low n slow butt but it came out great.  Now I'm just trying to find time to do another.  

    Good looking cooks.
  • JRWhiteeJRWhitee Posts: 2,780
    Welcome, nice job on cooks and pics.

    Large BGE 2006, Mini Max 2014 
    Founding Member of the Green Man Group cooking team.
    Johns Creek, Georgia

  • rjfalskirjfalski Posts: 13
    No worries, you're not the first to do that.  My first butt was an 8lb'er and I started it at night only to wake up early in the morning to an egg that went out (went out because I kept messing with it).  Of course I went through the same panic, but called everyone to cancel my first BBQ.  I re-lit the egg and continued to to cook the butt till the internal temp reached 190.........Get this, the entire time that passed was 24 HOURS! Yup. I totally figured it be jerky by then...How wrong I was!!! It just goes to show how unique this BGE really is.. the bone slide right out and the Mrs. said it was the best she'd ever had at that time.  I've realized this: You are only as good as the tools you use.

    My 3rd attempt at butts, I did 4 (33lbs total) at once for a buddy's kid's graduation earlier this month (24hr cook time at 220 with a DigiQ)...Again, perfection and everyone wanted to know my secret....All I did was put the meat in the BGE.. That's the secret.

  • Congrats and welcome to the asylum!
    I fully understand the love you feel for your Egg, this is just the tip of the Iceberg.
    Great first creation!
Sign In or Register to comment.