BBQ Chicken with White Sauce

toothpick · October 2012

Using Big Bob Gibson's BBQ Cook Book I tried "Bar-B-Q Chicken with White Sauce" this weekend. It was my first exposure to mayonnaise-based sauce. I was a skeptic of the white sauce, but I have to say it was VERY tasty!

Did a spatchcocked chicken for 2 hours at 350f indirect, quartered it and dipped it in the sauce.

Skiddymarker · October 2012

Saw a recipe for Alabama White Sauce some years ago, having never been to Alabama had no idea if it was real or not. Found it to be really good with hickory smoked chicken on the old Weber kettle.

Even better on the egg. We set it out as a side dip.

Thanks for sharing.

NibbleMeThis · November 2012

It took me YEARS to get up the nerve to try that one but when I did, I loved it. In fact it is now one of the top two smoked chicken recipes of mine.

But the very best chicken I have ever had was when I had some of the Big Bob Gibson style made by Chris Lilly in a cooking class. I followed the exact same recipe twice and it still didn't taste as good as the ones he made.

jfm0830 · November 2012

On paper that recipe didn't look good to me. Plus I am not a fan of mayo and when eating out I always have it removed from whatever I'm ordering. But like you I made the same recipe from the same cookbook this past spring and it was some great eating. The sauce was excellent. I went back to this recipe for the first meal on my new Egg in August and it was the best chicken I've ever ever made. My wife didn't know I had gotten my new Egg that day, but she noticed the difference right away and gave me 3 OMG's followed by saying it was the best chicken she'd ever tried.

So nice job toothpick! I am a bit jealous: Your sauce seemed to cling a little better than mine did. To anyone who is skeptical about this unusual tasting BBQ sauce, definitely give it a try. IT is a natural with chicken.

Griffin · November 2012

Beautiful looking dripping chicken. I'm with Chris and Jim, took me years to finally get around to trying it but it is some good stuff. You reminded me I need to make it again. Thanks.

SmokeyPitt · November 2012

OK, you all have convinced me to give this a try!

jfm0830 · November 2012

A word of warning to folks who try the Chris Lilly recipe from the Big Bob Gibsons BBQ Cookbook or the versions of it he has made available online. The recipe says it takes 3 hours, while I'd never spatchcocked a chicken before this I knew this had to be wrong. And it was. Mine took 1:30 & 1:45 like my BCC's always have. Toothpick said his was 2:00. But either way that isn't close to 3 hours. This comes into play because you flip the chicken at the midpoint. So don't get fooled by the 3 hour time mentioned in the recipe. Jim

toothpick · November 2012

Thanks for the positive remarks everyone. It really was tasty. Jim is dead on. I couldn't see how it was going to take 3 hours either. I waited for the skin to get nice, golden brown and then flipped it. I think in all honesty I took the bird off after about 1:50. By then it may have been a little bit too long--although it was still incredibly tender and juicy.

Jim, it's funny what you say about the sauce. That totally puzzled me. The sauce ran off almost completely by the time the chicken got to the table. I had a bowl of the sauce handy and kept spooning it on. We also had some hand-cut potato chips with dinner. This sauce was great on them too. Thanks again for the encouragement, guys.

jfm0830 · November 2012

While I'm sorry to hear that you had the problem with runny sauce, I'm also glad to know it wasn't just me. The first time out I flipped the bird and sprayed it with olive oil at the one hour mark ASSuming a 2 hour cook. It took only another 30 minutes total and I guessed that that wasn't enough time to cook off or absorb the olive oil. The second time I flipped it at 45 minutes and it was on for another hour as things would have it. It was less runny, but still runny.

This time I was ready for it though. I reserved half of the sauce and poured it into little bowls for dipping at the table. The strange thing is the picture in the book makes it look like it clings to the chicken like glue. Like I said, good to know it isn't just me.

BENTE · November 2012

i love that sauce. my gf does not eat mayo on anything. she laid out in the sun with mayo on when she was younger and has not eaten it since. but i may get her to try it. that is a big maybe.

scooter759 · November 2012

That sauce was the first recipe a tried after I got that book. Since the recipe calls for 2 cups of mayo, I just buy the 16oz squeeze bottle, mix up the sauce, and pour some right back into the mayo bottle to pass around the table.

Howdy, Stranger!

Forums

BBQ Chicken with White Sauce

Comments