I am willing to bet each of these products have their loyal followers, so this could get interesting. I am thinking about buying a new eggcessory and one of these two are in the crosshairs. I currently use my own two tier system out of 18" grate and 6" bolts. It has worked well, I feel I get maximum grill space but often I find I would like easier access to both levels. Thus, the CGW swing rack appeals to me but with a 15" top grate I feel I would be losing valuable grill space (assume someone is going to tell me to get another egg, I am working the wife on that already!).
I think my main goal is to get more volume and accessibility when doing raised direct. I also want to get something like the Spider so I can get closer to the coals for seers, without going in the coals, my wife is not fond of that idea.
Leaning towards the CGW and a small spider for seer.
Any suggestions or eggsperiences are appreciated, Thanks for the help.