Big Green Egg - EGGhead Forum - The Ultimate Cooking Experience...
Looking forward to a delicious Christmas dinner? Keep our Holiday Entertaining Publication handy throughout December for all your holiday dinner needs. But you can also find some of our favorites on our Country Christmas page, including Christmas Ham and Peach Cobbler. Happy cooking!

The 17th Annual EGGtoberfest was amazing - here are the highlights Click Here

Canadian EGGers- ?

edited November -1 in EggHead Forum
My wife's cousin came in this week end from Ottawa, with her daughter. Along with the Maple Syrup (I always ask for the Amber and she always bring the "B"), she also brought some SMOKED MEAT.

We sliced it up yesterday and we put it in a steamer to warm it up. The meat was really tasty and moist. It was lean too. I was expecting some fat but not much. I know the cut of meat is brisket, (or is it ?), but the way it was done it didn't have the brisket feel. I tried it again today and I didn't taste much SMOKE. It definitely has the taste of pastrami.

So my question is: Is SMOKED MEAT smoked ? If so, what kind of wood ? Have anyone here ever try to make SMOKED MEAT and get the same results as the Smoked Meat you have there ?


Gary Captol
Canoga Park, Ca.


  • Gary, my old dad used to say that if you ain't got timing, you ain't got nutthin.

    Montreal smoke meat (not SMOKED meat- the term is born from a Franco-English patois) devotees are fanatical to the point of being religious. I'm ridiculous about it, and I know it. MSM is a different animal from both corned beef and pastrami- in theory, at least, it's a brisket cured, smoked and then steamed just prior to service, with a cracked black pepper and coriander deckle which needs to be hand-cut (both very thin and very thick) and then stacked impossibly high on two slices of single-rye bread with mustard. The meat shouldn't be falling apart, per se, but should be tender to the point that the individual filaments of the brisket should be if not separate, then distinct.

    MSM is associated and allegedly has its origins with Anglo-Jewish Montreal, although today it's crossed language and ethnic lines. Schwartz's Delicatessen is (literally) internationally famous for its smoke meat, though over the years the quality has deteriorated (in my opinion, which is of course, correct). The best smoke meat I've tasted is not actually in Montreal, but is just west of the City on Ile Perrot in the form of Smoke Meat Pete. Smoke Meat Pete (Can't Beat Pete's Meat!) isn't as much a restaurant but a religious experience. Pete's meat cures hangovers. Pete's meat solves deficit crises. Pete's meat raises the dead. It's that good.

    Without even knowing what you ate (likely Dunn's or Lester's, though how the hell your cousin got meat across the border is beyond me), it was a pale imitation of the real thing. Believe me: you need to taste the real thing.

    MSM is smoked with maple wood. It's viciously difficult to find recipes online.

    Like I said at the beginning, your timing is excellent: as we speak, I'm in the process of my first attempt at making Montreal smoke meat for my inlaws who're actually from Montreal. I'll be updating the thread until Sunday when I plan on eating the sucker, and you can find it here:

    Wish me luck,

  • Little StevenLittle Steven Posts: 26,693
    I had smoked meat from Dunn's a couple of times two weeks ago and it was very good. I liked the "impossibly high" comment.



    Caledon, ON


  • BearBear Posts: 32
    As a teenager living in Montreal (NDG) I recall the classified ads listing literally dozens of ads for "smoke meat cutters". Everyone sold authentic MSM or so it seemed. Ben's was one of the best places to eat it in my opinion.

    Thanks for reminding me!!!!! :) :) :)

  • Little StevenLittle Steven Posts: 26,693
    And let's not forget Mike's Sous Marins


    Caledon, ON


  • BearBear Posts: 32
    Too true! I suported one to such an extent that the owner would gleefully shout "hear comes the rent" whenever I came in.

  • dugdbugdugdbug Posts: 244
    I grew up in DDO so I cast my vote for Chenoys!!! :woohoo:
  • MCRMCR Posts: 270
    I support this motion...

    Chenoy's in the West island on St-Jean. Many of our trip to Montreal and East include a stop at Chenoy's
Sign In or Register to comment.